3 min read

WESTBROOK – Residents of Westbrook’s Birdland neighborhood have filed suit against the city over a consent agreement that would allow Pike Industries to operate a nearby quarry.

The suit, filed Thursday in Cumberland County Superior Court on behalf of the Birdland Neighborhood Alliance, alleges the consent agreement violates city zoning requirements and the state constitution. The lawsuit asks the court to find the agreement unconstitutional and invalid, and to award members of the Alliance costs and attorneys’ fees for pursuing litigation.

City officials recently approved the agreement as a way to avoid going to trial over Pike’s efforts to continue operations at the quarry on Spring Street.

The agreement was subject to revisions before its approval in September by the City Council. Pike made concessions in accepting the revised agreement, including limiting production blasts to eight times a year.

However, some neighboring businesses and residents are unhappy with the approval. In the lawsuit, David Lourie, attorney for the Birdland residents’ group, claims the agreement sidesteps city zoning requirements.

The amended agreement was first released to the public only an hour before a special City Council meeting called to approve it on Sept. 8, according to the lawsuit.

Advertisement

“The City never conducted any formal ‘public hearing’ inviting the public to discuss the proposed zoning amendment as is required by the Zoning Enabling Act,” the lawsuit states.

The lawsuit further alleges the agreement violates the separation of powers article of the Maine Constitution by asking a judge to legislate zoning changes.

The council’s decision authorizes the city to consent to a court judgment granting Pike the right to conduct mineral extraction activities, including explosive blasting and the crushing of rock.

The Birdland neighborhood is comprised of 40 to 50 single-family homes in the southern part of the city. It was once a rural residential neighborhood, but over time became surrounded by commercial development.

Court documents indicate the residents sought litigation due to perceptions that increased activity at the quarry could negatively impact quality of life in the neighborhood.

“The use, value and enjoyment of the property of members of BNA is adversely affected by the Order and Agreement to allow mineral extraction and blasting to be conducted where prohibited by the Westbrook Land Use Ordinance,” the lawsuit states.

Advertisement

The city previously determined that quarrying there is illegal because Blue Rock, the company from which Pike bought the quarry in 2005, failed to meet conditions of its 1968 quarry permit. That led Pike to file suit, arguing that the city was unfair to deny it a right to operate now when it had knowingly allowed quarrying at the site for decades.

City Administrator Jerre Bryant was not surprised when he found out about the Birdland lawsuit. The only recourse for those dissatisfied with the consent agreement was to file suit, he said.

Bryant said it has been difficult to craft a compromise when some involved simply want the quarry to disappear. He said this latest lawsuit is an additional complication and underscores the difficulty of finding a compromise.

“We serve everyone in the community. We certainly continue to work with everyone on this and other issues,” he said.

Birdland residents are not the only parties dissatisfied with the agreement. Three companies are interveners in the lawsuit between Pike and the city, and only one of them approves of the consent agreement.

Idexx Laboratories, a biotechnology firm located near the quarry at the Five Star Industrial Park, was part of a motion to delay a trial over this matter, but two other neighboring businesses continue to oppose the compromise.

Advertisement

Over the summer, the city, Pike and Idexx worked out the consent agreement. The other interveners in the case, Artel Inc. and Smiling Hill Farm, agree with residents who say they were shut out of the negotiations.

Artel, which makes instruments for precise measuring of liquids, and the farm, which wants to build a 20-acre glass greenhouse, worry quarry operations would damage their businesses.

Artel has filed a motion in Maine Business and Consumer Court asking a judge to reject the consent agreement.

Superior Court Justice Thomas E. Humphrey is expected to render a decision on the consent agreement soon.

Comments are no longer available on this story