SOUTH PORTLAND – According to budget numbers tossed out at a joint meeting last week between the City Council and the Board of Education in South Portland, local property tax bills could climb as much as 6.25 percent if a host of looming revenue shortfalls don’t get resolved by the end of the fiscal year.
“If we assumed the worst in everything, that would add 98 cents on mill rate,” said Mayor Jerry Jalbert, on Monday.
That would mean a tax hike of $196 to the median single-family home in South Portland, assessed at $200,000, which currently pays $3,340 per year, based on the current tax rate of $16.70 per $1,000 of assessed value.
“No city councilor was comfortable with that whatsoever,” said Jalbert. “We can’t raise property taxes that much. There’s just no way. It’s just too severe an increase.”
Instead, guidance given by city councilors at the joint meeting was that tax bills should be allowed to increase by no more than 3 to 3.5 percent.
“That’s optimistic,” said school board Chairman Tappen Fitzgerald, on Monday.
“The problem we have, and it’s the same problem the City Council has, is that all of the numbers out of Augusta are so soft,” said Fitzgerald. “We just don’t know what those numbers are. They literally change every day. But at least the council kind of understands, as we do with them, where the other side is coming from.”
The Jan. 15 joint session was the third of the current fiscal year, but was the first at which the council issued actual guidance for the upcoming budget season.
Among the councilors, Michael Pock stumped for the smallest tax hike, holding the line at a 2-to-3 percent increase, while Tom Blake was OK with a jump of as much as 5 percent.
During the inaugural address for his mayoral term last year, Blake called for a maximum 1 percent increase in property taxes, a goal that was nearly met when the final tally rang in at 1.28 percent.
Superintendent Suzanne Godin is slated to have her budget proposal in school board hands by March 10, said Fitzgerald. The city charter calls on the full municipal budget to be presented to the council by the third Monday in March, which this year falls on the 17th.
Chief among the challenges this year will be how to deal with an expected shortfall in state revenue sharing. Last year, as a way to balance his proposed biennial budget, Gov. Paul LePage proposed a temporary suspension of revenue sharing, a program created in the 1970s that kicks back a portion of the state sales tax as a way to help lower property tax bills. The legislature later restored two-thirds of that funding, but left a $40 million budget hole. Instead, it created a task force to find cost savings to cover that gap. If the task force fails to come through, the missing money will automatically come from revenue sharing.
In South Portland, where collected sales taxes in 2012 rang up to more than $51 million, that would mean the loss of $793,000 the city was expecting to flow into its coffers from the state. According to Jalbert, making up that amount of money from property taxes would add 23 cents to the mill rate, or 3 cents more than the total mill rate increase voted in last June for the current fiscal year.
In addition, there are fixed costs to consider on the school side. The first payments on the $41.5 million high school renovation bond come due during the fiscal year that starts July 1, and that will add 17 cents to the mill rate all by itself, according to city Finance Director Greg L’Heureux.
“Obviously the big issue for us is the high school,” said Fitzgerald. “The cost of the building is very expensive, although it’s worth every penny.”
Then there are contracted labor costs. On the school side, spending on salaries and benefits is pegged to increase $650,000 next year, said Fitzgerald.
That and other increased costs, combined with possible additional shortfalls in funding from the state – such as in the annual school subsidy – could be offset by an $899,125 windfall received last year.
That money, a late adjustment made by the Department of Education after the legislature overrode the governor’s budget veto, could not be rolled into this year’s school budget because the public had already weighed in at the annual school budget validation vote, locking in how much the school department could spend.
Instead, $300,000 was used by the city to lower this year’s tax rate impact of the high school bond, while the rest was divvied up into various school reserve funds. How much of that money, if any, will come back as a “starting balance” for next year’s school budget remains uncertain, Jalbert and Fitzgerald agree.
According to Jalbert, the disposition of those funds was the topic of a “protracted discussion” at the joint meeting, including “a little disagreement” between L’Heureux, Godin and school Finance Director Rafe Forland. Most of the council, Jalbert said, seemed to leave the meeting “thoroughly confused” over the so-called “starting balance” for the next school budget.
What was clear, however, was the line in the sand drawn by the council, said Jalbert. School board reaction to that demand was “benign,” he said.
“I wouldn’t say there was any pushback at all, really,” said Jalbert.
However, Fitzgerald saw it a bit differently, concluding that there is, as of yet, nothing solid to push back against.
“I don’t think anybody was under the assumption that we were going to go with the numbers we have right now,” he said. “What we are working with is so preliminary, it’s very, very premature in the game to be deciding where we are going to come in. Frankly, the numbers are so soft that we just don’t know anything at this point.”
For Jalbert, however, now is the time to start raising red flags.
“The numbers we are talking about right now are so huge, my concern is that we may end up having to cut services, but still end up with a tax increase,” he said.
Comments are no longer available on this story