Less than one-quarter of those covered by the state’s Dirigo Health subsidized insurance program were previously uninsured – a shortcoming state health officials want to address later this week when they set the program’s budget and enrollment goals for 2006.
The size of that budget also could trigger a court appeal of an assessment or tax on private insurance companies and self-insured businesses, which are waiting to see how much they will have to pay to keep Dirigo Health going next year.
While the parties involved say they haven’t made up their minds yet and won’t until the Dirigo board meeting scheduled for Thursday afternoon, industry watchers say the likelihood of a court appeal will grow with the size of the Dirigo budget.
Legislators in 2003 created Dirigo Health insurance with the goal of insuring the state’s 130,000 uninsured. The program was started with $53 million in state money made available thanks to a one-time cash infusion from the federal government to help states struggling with escalating Medicaid costs. Now the Dirigo agency must charge a so-called savings offset payment to have enough money to operate through next year.
Trish Riley, head of the governor’s Office of Health Policy and Finance, said Monday the program has not been very successful at insuring the uninsured, and only 1,000 to 2,000 of the 8,300 people now enrolled in the plan were previously without coverage. Many, however, were under-insured, carrying high deductibles.
“The goal here is to get back to our roots,” Riley said, and at least double the number of uninsured enrollees in 2006. Part of the plan will be to work with Anthem, which runs Dirigo Health enrollment for the state, and find out what can be done better.
“We’re not happy with Anthem’s progress in reaching the uninsured,” Riley said, and “they’re not happy either.”
While Anthem is a partner with the state in the Dirigo program, the company also weighed in along with others to oppose the formula the Dirigo Health agency is using to fund the insurance program going forward.
The formula is supposed to measure savings in healthcare costs brought about because of the Dirigo Health legislation of 2003. The Dirigo Health board of directors had claimed those savings were $137 million, but the superintendent of the state’s Bureau of Insurance ruled at the end of October the savings were only $43.7 million.
The amount is important because the legislation says an assessment of up to 4 percent of paid insurance claims – estimated at $48 million – can only be billed to private insurers and self-insured businesses if at least that much was saved by the system because of Dirigo Health.
All but $10 million of the $43.7 million in savings was attributed to voluntary caps on expenses and profits at the state’s hospitals; $7.3 million in increased and more timely Medicaid payments to doctors and hospitals; and, only $2.7 million due to less bad debt and charity care because of coverage of the uninsured.
The Dirigo board can assess the full $43.7 million if it wants, and that assessment can be passed along to consumers since there’s nothing in the Dirigo legislation to prevent it.
Gov. John Baldacci late last week threatened to introduce legislation to block the assessment from being passed along, comparing the state’s insurance companies to price gougers in the oil industry.
Baldacci said it was “unacceptable” to raise rates to pay for Dirigo, saying the savings under the program represent “monies that belong to Maine people.”
In reality, the Dirigo legislation allows the assessment to be included in the premium consumers pay.
“The governors office, among others, agreed,” in 2003 that the assessment could be passed onto consumers through the premium, said Katherine Pelletreau of the Maine Association of Health Plans, one of the groups that opposes the Dirigo board’s saving offset formula.
If the governor introduces legislation to block that now, she said, “We’ll fight it out in the Legislature.”
Kristine Ossenfort of the Maine State Chamber, another group that testified at the insurance hearings, said she was “surprised and disappointed” at the governor’s reaction.
She said a move was made to prohibit the assessment from being passed onto consumers and “that provision was taken out” of the law.
Riley agreed the insurers negotiated to allow the assessment to be tacked onto premiums, if needed, but that was not the spirit of the legislation.
“Their job was to negotiate their rates,” and get hospitals to bring charges down based on Dirigo savings, Riley said.
Comments are no longer available on this story