The city of South Portland appears to be poised to fire a public works employee for totaling one of the city’s two new high-tech garbage trucks that cost the city $360,000.
While the driver, John Talbot, is certainly at fault in the accident, he doesn’t deserve to lose his job. He freely admits he made a mistake, and he probably shouldn’t have been driving the truck in the first place.
The accident should prompt the city to take a hard look at how Talbot, who lost his driver’s license because he was a habitual offender, wound up driving one of the city’s most expensive trucks, and whether the training providing for driving these and other specialized vehicles is adequate.
This incident also calls into question the state’s practice of giving conditional commercial licenses to people who have had their personal licenses revoked, as Talbot had. While allowing people to get to and from work with a conditional license makes sense, it doesn’t make sense to allow people to drive as their occupation after they have had their license revoked.
Talbot, who is 33, was granted a commercial vehicle license last November, after his driver’s license had been suspended in 2004 for several traffic violations, including speeding, running a stop sign and operating with a suspended license. After 18 months, Talbot was eligible to apply for a work-restricted license. He did so with the support of the city, which had to co-sign the petition to the Bureau of Motor Vehicles requesting the license.
Five months after he had obtained the license, Talbot was behind the wheel of one of South Portland’s new, automated garbage trucks, which are not easy to operate. The driver is responsible for maneuvering a large truck that’s top-heavy when it’s full, as well as a robotic arm.
The training the city is providing to the drivers of these trucks is of particular concern to the local chapter of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, according to the chairman of the chapter, Bob Sevigny, who said the union’s position is that drivers of the trucks need specialized training.
Talbot said he spent one day with another driver, who showed him how to operate the vehicle and accompanied him on the route. Seven weeks later, on April 11, Talbot was driving on Highland Avenue when he rolled the truck as he attempted to turn onto Plymouth Road, according to a witness to the accident.
Talbot cracked his vertebrae and was pinned inside the cab for more than an hour after the truck tipped over. The city was able to collect $130,000 in insurance money for the truck, which cost $183,000 new.
On May 30, Talbot’s driver’s license was fully restored by the state. While Talbot shouldn’t be allowed to drive any more city vehicles, he should keep his job as a laborer in the public works department – a job he held before he started driving city garbage trucks. Talbot was simply trying to make a little more money, and then he made what appears to be an honest and costly mistake.
That mistake, however, shouldn’t stop the city from making a hard and honest assessment of the training and experience it is requiring of the people it puts behind the wheel of expensive trucks that are large enough to do serious damage if handled improperly.
Brendan Moran, editor
Comments are no longer available on this story