4 min read

Cap’n Newick’s bustled Sunday and nearly ran out of fresh fish to fry, reminding long-time patrons and staff of better times at the South Portland restaurant.

Newick’s has been packed with customers for lunch and dinner, since its owner announced last week that the neighborhood institution will close after 31 years.

The huge family-style restaurant – known for generous fried fish platters – is no longer profitable, according to Newick’s Hospitality Group. It will close on May 21.

Newick’s Hospitality Group also plans to shutter Cap’n Newick’s restaurant in Merrimack, N.H., leaving only the flagship restaurant in Dover, N.H.

“Our Merrimack and South Portland locations have not been profitable for a number of years,” according a statement posted on the company’s Web site.

“Economic factors have forced us to restructure our companies to preserve Newick’s for future generations of seafood lovers.”

Advertisement

The company blames rising competition from large chain restaurants for a decline in customers.

John “Jack” Newick, the company founder, refused to comment further on the closings.

Newick’s restaurant and site on Broadway are valued at more than $1.3 million, according to the South Portland Assessor’s Office. But it is unclear what the future plans are for the property.

Customers, meanwhile, flocked to Newick’s to express condolences and get one last seafood dinner before the closing.

Workers also were eager to share memories and savor the final days. Two of Newick’s 60 staff members are third-generation employees.

“The closing is like a death in the family,” said Gail Berenson, Newick’s hospitality manager.

Advertisement

Last Sunday, Berenson wore a white button pinned to her shirt. It had the Newick’s lobster logo and a simple message written in red: “31 years” – her time of employment.

Berenson showed restaurant visitors another motto, scrawled in black marker on the wooden cashier’s stand.

It was three letters – “NFL” – and stands for “Newick’s for life,” Berenson said. The motto, she said, reflects the loyalty of staff and patrons.

“I’ve been here since Day 1, and I’ll be here on the last day,” said Berenson, as she greeted one customer after another by name.

“Hey, Gail, I’ll help you find a job,” shouted one long-time diner standing in the restaurant’s nautical-themed gift shop, as he waited for an empty table. “You can use me for a reference. You’re great.”

Ann and John Ridge of South Portland lingered in the reception area and gift shop, waiting for their daughter to arrive for dinner. The Ridges are regulars, and expressed dismay about the closing.

Advertisement

“I like the people here. Everyone is so nice,” said Ann Ridge, who always orders the baked haddock.

“The prices are fair,” added John Ridge, who wore a Boston Red Sox cap. “We’ve been coming here since they first opened.”

The Ridges recalled the days when the 320-seat Newick’s was the go-to restaurant in South Portland, a destination for tourists and locals.

Jack Newick of New Hampshire opened the South Portland Newick’s on March 2, 1976. The restaurant burned down six weeks later, but immediately was rebuilt.

Newick’s on Broadway was an instant success. The restaurant expanded in the 1980s to accommodate the turn-away crowds.

Famous people as well as ordinary folk headed to Newick’s for the fried clams, clam chowder and seafood platters.

Advertisement

Berenson recalls supplying former U.S. Sen. William Cohen of Maine and his entourage with takeout meals for their plane trip back to Washington, D.C. Secret Service agents who guarded President George Bush Sr. used to stop in at Newick’s, when the Bushes summered in Maine.

“Everyone has eaten at Newick’s – the very rich and the very poor,” Berenson said.

She keeps a scrapbook of photos of important moments in Newick’s history. One 20-year-old photo shows lines of customers extending outside the restaurant into the dirt parking lot. The big occasion was Mother’s Day.

“Those were the days before a gazillion restaurants opened at the mall,” Berenson said.

Newick’s hardly has changed through the years. Today the wait staff wears khaki pants and Navy blue sport shirts, instead of polyester dresses and white nursing shoes.

Meals are served on plastic, blue-checkered table cloths. Fishermen’s buoys and wood lobster traps adorn the place. There’s a tropical fish aquarium in the reception area.

Advertisement

Plastic plates and baskets have replaced paper plates.

The atmosphere has stayed friendly and casual, with neighbor waving to neighbor in the large dining room.

Newick’s still does a steady business, but the tour buses do not stop as often. Locals also have more choices when dining out.

Younger customers often head to modern restaurant chains near the mall, such as Outback, Eggspectations and the Longhorn Steakhouse.

Newick’s business also may be affected by changing attitudes about food and how it affects health. Americans regularly get health warnings about not eating too much fried food.

Newick’s serves broiled and baked seafood. But its specialty is fried fish – haddock, clams, scallops and shrimp. Dinners are hand-breaded, from the haddock tenders to the coconut shrimp. The mouth-watering smell of fried fish wafts through the restaurant and outside into the parking lot.

Fried onion rings are a popular side, and there often is cream pie for dessert. But Berenson believes it’s the friendliness that customers will remember most about Newick’s.

“We’re family-owned and family-run,” Berenson said. “Everyone – the staff, the customers – is like family to us.”

Newick

Comments are no longer available on this story