4 min read

When resident Tom Blake showed up for the South Portland City Council meeting Oct. 15, City Hall was dark and the doors locked.

Likewise, resident Gary Crosby searched for the council agenda online Oct. 15, as he planned to attend the Monday night meeting and speak during the public hearing.

But Crosby found no mention of the council meeting on the city of South Portland Web site.

Both residents later learned that the city council canceled its regularly scheduled meeting without notifying the public.

That decision led to a call for the city attorney to review the city charter and to allegations that the council denied the public its ability to speak out on critical issues of the moment, including an expensive school bond.

Although Mayor Claude Morgan has said the meeting cancellation was due to a lack of an agenda, some residents see a deeper problem. They complain the council failed to follow the city rules and effectively shut out the public.

Advertisement

“There is absolutely no excuse for the city council not to hold its regularly scheduled meetings,” said Crosby, who had hoped to speak against a $56 million high school construction bond on the Nov. 6 ballot.

The city council’s regular meetings, which are televised, are scheduled for the first and third Monday of each month. “The public expects the council to be there,” Crosby said later.

The cancellation was made Oct. 8, when Mayor Claude Morgan announced at a council workshop that there were not enough items to warrant a meeting.

“I am not commenting on this,” Morgan said later, after several residents complained.

But Louis Maietta Jr., who is running for city council, also complained publicly at a televised candidates’ forum, saying he found the decision “disturbing.”

Maietta, a former councilor, said the city charter requires the council to meet twice a month. The days and times of the meetings are written in the city ordinance.

Advertisement

“The charter states that the council ‘shall’ meet twice a month. Shall is a big word and it is not being followed,” Maietta said afterward.

The charter states: “The city council shall … establish by ordinance or resolution a regular place and time for holding its regular meetings, and shall meet regularly at least twice a month.”

He also criticized the council for canceling a meeting in August without rescheduling it.

Maietta said he worries that the council is setting a new precedent, in violation of city rules and without input from voters. The regular council meetings also provide a forum for residents to address any concerns they have.

“I have heard there were people in the public who had full intention of attending the council meeting to talk about the huge amount of money for the high school,” Maietta said, referring to the $56 million bond proposal.

“These people were snowballed,” he said. “They were shut out.”

Advertisement

But City Attorney Mary Kahl disagrees with that view.

She responded to the complaints in an Oct. 19 memo she e-mailed to the seven-member council.

“I do not read the charter… as meaning that a regular meeting cannot be canceled,” whether it is due to weather or lack of agenda items, she wrote.

In a phone interview this week, Kahl emphasized that while canceling a city council meeting is unusual, she believes the members did nothing wrong.

Morgan made the decision to cancel the meeting, and informed fellow councilors at an Oct. 8 council workshop. No one objected.

Kahl said that the council’s practice is to meet “regularly” on the first and third Monday of the month. If the council had a pattern of canceling meetings, then it would be a problem, she said.

Advertisement

Kahl also said the council is under no obligation to make up canceled meetings.

Although the city ordinance details the steps for posting and holding rescheduled meetings, they are not mandated, she said.

Kahl said, in her view, “there was nothing on the agenda Oct. 15 that was time sensitive that could not wait until the next meeting.”

However, there was one item that the city council did have to act on, and a special council meeting was called on Oct. 22.

The council had to act quickly on a housekeeping item requiring members officially to set polling hours, at least seven days in advance of the Nov. 6 elections.

The next regularly scheduled council meeting is Nov. 5.

Advertisement

Councilor Linda Boudreau said this week that she understands the concerns raised by some residents. But, at the same time, Boudreau said that “the mayor, working with the city manager, felt there was not the need to bring the council together.

“I am not going to judge their decision. The mayor and city manager were trying to do the best they could in the situation.”

Likewise, Blake – the local land trust president and a city council candidate – says he understands the pressures on council members to attend numerous meetings.

“The city council works extremely hard,” Blake said to councilors at an Oct. 22 workshop and special meeting.

But he added that the council should try harder to notify the public when it cancels meetings.

“I came down here expecting that the meeting would be held,” Blake told council members. “You need to make every effort to let the people know.”

Advertisement

He noted that many people watch council proceedings on public access TV at home. Broadcasting a message would have helped inform the public, he said.

Crosby said he believes there is rarely a lack of issues to discuss in a city of 25,000 people, with a budget of $80 million.

“Even if there are no issues, the council needs to have a regularly set time and place for the public to address what is on their mind,” he said.

“We were three weeks out from an election to decide an expensive bond issue,” he said. “Give people the chance to speak on it. I and other residents in this city have the right to be heard.”

Comments are no longer available on this story