Some call it politics as usual. It is actually the age-old struggle between power and principle.
The town of Gray is hiring an economic development director, or trying to. For several years, Gray has used the services of a professional planning analyst, George Thebarge, to encourage business and community development. In addition to writing complex ordinances and supporting the Planning Board, he has brought in hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of grants. These grants have substantially improved the appearance and safety of the village area. Storefronts have been dramatically redesigned, sidewalks and crosswalks built, dead trees removed, and further plans drafted using the latest software tools.
The previous town council believed that the work was so successful that a full-time economic director and planner should be budgeted and hired.
Now that the money is budgeted, the current town council has other ideas for the position. In particular, some members believe that the town would be better served by a business cheerleader, someone who will promote the town in the eyes of potential employers.
Complicating the situation, some citizens have been vocally skeptical of the success of Mr. Thebarge. For example, they cite his neglect of neighboring property-owners during the Northbrook TIF negotiations. Of course, this was as much the fault of the previous Town Council, including myself. I still regret our oversight.
The Gray Town Charter is pretty clear about who is authorized to hire and fire personnel. It gives the council authority to appoint the town manager and the tax assessor, but that’s all. The charter also gives the council the authority to create offices and departments, through the town’s Administrative Code. That ordinance was so obsolete that it was repealed entirely a few years ago, deferring government organization to the town manager. The charter does not authorize the council to hire and fire individuals, or even confirm their appointment.
The reason for this separation of powers should be clear. The charter protects the town against political appointees, influence, favoritism, rewards, cronyism, patronage or purges.
During her tenure, Town Manager Deborah Cabana has hired a finance director, two code enforcement officers, and two Fire-Rescue chiefs without interference from the council. In the latter case, she wisely selected a panel of emergency services experts to help her interview and evaluate the candidates. But the decision, and responsibility, was hers. The employees work for her, not the council.
However, in this instance, the council has created its own hiring committee. This committee has created its own job description, reviewed applications and held its own interviews.
The town manager is now in a difficult situation. She could ignore the committee, conducting her own search at peril to her own job and working relationship with the council. Or she could interpret any committee recommendation as direction from her bosses, the Town Council, despite its doubtful legality. Finally, she could follow orders but refuse to accept responsibility for the result, at the cost of her own integrity.
The town manager is in a difficult situation, yes, but the council put her squarely there. Rather than seek voter approval of a change to the charter to give itself hiring authority, the council is trying to evade the charter. When a government fails to follow its own rules, the people start to wonder why they should abide by the law either. When the people see power win out over principle, they lose faith in their government, or even in democracy.
However, there is hope. There is a center road. There is a possible compromise, where everyone can save face. It’s not rocket surgery.
The answer is to hire both a business relations specialist and a planning specialist, each half-time. Put the business representative in charge of presenting the face of Gray to the world. Have a planner who will continue writing grants, updating regulations, and developing detailed plans. Evaluate the former on the net job increase in Gray, and the latter on how many grant dollars are awarded to the town.
Goodness knows that the town can benefit from both sets of skills if its economy is to grow.
Mark D. Grover is a resident of Gray.
Comments are no longer available on this story