3 min read

CAPE ELIZABETH – The town of Cape Elizabeth has requested that a federal judge dismiss a portion of a lawsuit filed by Verizon Wireless this summer because the cellular company failed to pursue an appeal in Maine Superior Court, as required by state law.

The town’s Code Enforcement Officer Ben McDougal denied Verizon Wireless a permit in March to install telecommunications equipment on an existing water tower at 11 Avon Road.

Verizon Wireless appealed to the town’s Zoning Board of Appeals two times in the past year, but in June, the zoning board decided to uphold the code enforcement officer’s decision to not issue the permit because the proposal did not meet all of the requirements of the town’s zoning ordinance.

Represented by attorney Scott Anderson of Verrill Dana in Portland Verizon Wireless filed its lawsuit against the town in July in U.S. District Court in Portland claiming that the zoning board violated a federal law as well as a local zoning ordinance when it denied its proposal to install equipment on the tower.

The 69-year-old tower, owned by the Portland Water District, has not been used for water storage since 2007.

Several residents have spoken against Verizon’s proposal, citing lowered property values, increased traffic and negative visual impact on a nearby neighborhood.

Advertisement

In its lawsuit, Verizon Wireless said, “the proposed facility will provide additional service coverage in the southeastern portion of Cape Elizabeth.”

Verizon claims that using the water tower should be permitted under the town’s zoning ordinance because it fits the ordinance’s definition of an “Alternate Tower Structure.” It also says in its lawsuit that the 80-foot-tall water tower is an “eligible facility” under the federal Spectrum Act, because its proposal would not “substantially change” the physical dimensions of the existing structure.

Cape Elizabeth Town Manager Michael McGovern declined to comment on the town’s Sept. 9 response and said he prefers to only discuss lawsuits when they have been decided.

The town, represented by John J. Wall III of Portland law firm Monaghan Leahy, is requesting that a judge partially dismiss the lawsuit on the basis that the cell company has run out of time to appeal the town’s zoning board’s decision in state court.

Verizon Wireless has three weeks from the Sept. 9 motion to file its response, according to Anderson.

“Placement of cell towers is not purely a state or local issue,” he said. “Cell tower placement is governed by a blend of local and federal law.”

Advertisement

According to Anderson, the case “is most appropriately addressed” in one federal court proceeding, and for a few reasons.

First, he said, the claims are related. Both the federal law and the town’s zoning ordinance “were enacted to encourage carriers to install antennas on existing structures, so as to avoid the need for new towers,” said Anderson.

He said the federal court has the authority to hear both the state and federal claims. He said Cape Elizabeth does not dispute that, but believes that “the interpretation of its local ordinance is uniquely a local issue and, therefore, the federal court should abstain from exercising its authority.”

Installing wireless communication equipment on the water tower is not a “uniquely local issue,” said Anderson. And because it is regulated by both a local ordinance and a federal law it is more appropriate for a federal court to review all of the claims.

Anderson also said addressing the lawsuit in federal court rather than in two separate court proceedings, “is simply more efficient and quicker and likely less expensive.”

“Verizon is trying to improve cell phone service in Cape as quickly as possible,” he said.

Comments are no longer available on this story