SOUTH PORTLAND – Proposed state legislation to ban new cruiser-mounted traffic cameras like the ones South Portland police recently acquired could be amended to allow use of the technology under guidelines to protect public privacy.
Sen. Dennis Damon, a Hancock County Democrat, proposed the legislation to ban the cameras in Maine. But he said this week that, after listening to testimony at a public hearing Feb. 5 before the Legislature’s Transportation Committee, he now believes the cameras can be a useful law enforcement tool as long as limits are in place.
The automated license plate recognition system cameras are mounted on top of police cruisers. They provide a photographic record of vehicles and their license plates at specific times and locations, and automatically alert police if a vehicle is stolen or its owner wanted for a crime.
“I don’t want to ban the devices,” said Damon, who is Senate chairman of the Transportation Committee. “I just don’t want to see abuse of the technology.”
Damon, along with the Maine Civil Liberties Union, had raised concerns that the cameras would constitute an invasion of privacy because they record all vehicles, not just those of wanted criminals. He and the MCLU said they worried about the data the cameras collect being stolen or sold or used to inappropriately track innocent people, such as those attending political events.
However, Damon said he now would be satisfied if guidelines governing use of the technology are written into state law. “If that can happen,” Damon said, “I think everybody is fine.”
South Portland police Chief Edward Googins, who testified against a ban of the technology at the public hearing in Augusta, said on Monday, “That’s good news he’s thinking along those lines.”
Googins said he believes the testimony he and others presented in support of the cameras “was pretty enlightening to a lot of people that didn’t understand the technology.”
South Portland police are believed to be the first in Maine to get the new cameras, which photograph vehicle license plates as a police cruiser moves down the street, automatically alerting police if a vehicle license plate is on a “hot list” – a national database of license plates of interest to law enforcement.
Police say the cameras will make police and the public safer, and help in such situations as Amber Alerts, which are issued when a child has been abducted.
South Portland police got three cameras last month and mounted them on a police cruiser. A federal grant covered the $22,000 cost.
Googins in his testimony stressed that the new automated license plate reader system only reads license plate numbers – the names of the owners do not pop up on the cruiser’s computer laptop. Only if an alarm sounds about the license plate will the officer take steps to learn more about the vehicle and whether law enforcement action is warranted.
Googins also told the committee that South Portland has developed a standard operating procedure to govern use of the cameras. The procedure, which he submitted to legislators for review, contains such provisions as limiting retention of the images the cameras record to 30 days, and controlling access to the stored information.
However, Shenna Bellows, executive director of the MCLU, said that organization has concerns about South Portland’s policy. “We are concerned that 30 days is too long to maintain this database of everyone’s information,” she said.
In this information age, she said, “it’s not a question of if the data will be breached, it’s a question of when the data will be breached and what the consequences are to people who have not done anything wrong.”
Bellows, who testified in favor of the ban at the public hearing, said the MCLU also is concerned because oversight of the police department’s program will be internal, not done by an external agency.
She said that what is needed if the technology is to be used are “not just standard operating procedures but statutory guidelines and safeguards.”
Damon said he plans to recommend that a task force made up of representatives from the MCLU, law enforcement, and the general public be created to come up with the guidelines.
Comments are no longer available on this story