SOUTH PORTLAND–Don’t raise taxes, but don’t cut police and firefighter jobs. Support the school budget. Reject the school budget – and fire the board and the school superintendent in the process.
Those were some of the mixed messages that the South Portland City Council heard from residents Monday night during the first public hearing on the proposed 2010-2011 city budget. The $67 million city budget proposal is made up of three parts: the $27.1 million municipal budget; the $37.9 million school budget; and more than $2 million in county taxes.
The total city budget as proposed would raise the current tax rate of $14.70 per $1,000 of assessed property value by 19 cents to $14.89. That would translate to an additional $38 per year added to the tax bill of a $200,000 home.
The council has already begun a series of workshops on the new budget, which will take effect July 1. The council is tentatively scheduled to take a final vote on the city budget on May 24.
The council’s meeting on Monday, April 5, was the first public hearing on both the school and municipal budget proposals.
But before listening to public comment from the crowd of about 70 people filling the council chambers, councilors listened to short presentations on the both the school and municipal budget proposals.
What both of those budgets have in common is that they reduce spending but still require a tax increase. That’s because both the school and municipal sides of the city are expected to experience declining revenues in the new fiscal year but have an increase in fixed costs.
It’s not clear what the council’s reaction will be to the budget proposals. A majority of councilors in January said they wanted to see little or no tax increase, saying that city taxpayers can’t afford to pay more in the economic recession. Councilors did not say how they might vote on the budget during the public hearing.
The new 2010-2011 school budget of $37.9 million that the Board of Education approved last month is nearly $1.6 million or 4 percent less than the current school budget of $39.4 million.
The budget is now before the council, which sets the bottom line on school spending. The school budget would eliminate 25 positions, ranging from teachers to a truck driver. Many of the jobs are currently filled, so the cuts would entail layoffs.
However, that budget still would result in a tax increase, due to a reduction in state aid to education of more than $1 million and the addition of more than $506,623 in the budget to start a capital reserve account to pay for proposed improvements at the high school and the city’s two middle schools.
The addition of the capital reserve account requires a tax hike, increasing the tax rate by 14 cents. On a home valued at $200,000, that would translate to an additional $28 per year in taxes.
School Superintendent Suzanne Godin told the board that the budget is “fiscally responsible” and said it prepares the city for future funding of the capital improvements needed at the aging high school and middle schools.
Some of the more than 20 residents addressing the council endorsed the school budget.
Eric Kingsley said he supported the school budget and the tax increase involved, which he termed “moderate.”
“The Republican in me shivers when I say this, but I support the tax increase,” Kingsley said.
However, he said that he wants to see more long-term planning for improving education in the city or he and other families with children will leave.
“I love South Portland. It’s a great city,” he said. “But I love my kids more.”
Several other speakers also urged the council to work together with the school board to develop five-year and 10-year plans for improving school buildings and education.
But Ray Lee told the council that there are “a lot of suffering people” in the city who can’t afford a tax increase. “The school budget should be sent back,” he said.
Albert DiMillo, an accountant who is a frequent critic of school spending practices, urged the council to “get rid of the superintendent, get rid of the school board,” because he said the budget “is wrong.”
DiMillo criticized the school department for overspending and having too many administrators. Gary Crosby suggested the school board hold a public workshop with DiMillo to “hash out” his budget ideas. “I think it would be very educational for the public,” Crosby said.
He said the school board shouldn’t be setting aside money to help pay for improvements to South Portland High School when voters haven’t said whether they approve a $41.9 million plan to renovate and expand the high school. Some board members want the issue to go to voters in November.
Crosby praised the proposed municipal budget because it calls for a tax increase of less than 1 percent, which Crosby called “pretty good.”
He and other speakers laid much of the blame for the budget woes on Augusta. Because of its own revenue shortfalls, the state has cut back on state revenue sharing to municipalities and schools.
City Manager James Gailey’s $27.1 million municipal budget proposal is $322,156 or 1.17 percent less than this year’s budget of more than $27.4 million.
To cut spending, it calls for such measures as the elimination of 7.75 full-time city positions that currently are vacant. Those would include two police and two firefighter positions and half of a children’s librarian position.
The city manager’s budget calls for a .93 percent tax increase – which would translate to an extra 4 cents on the tax rate.
Gailey said that while municipal spending is down, the city will receive less in revenues in the new fiscal year and see an increase in fixed costs such as employee health insurance and fuel.
Rick Lee asked the council not to cut police and firefighter positions because they’re necessary for public safety. “Something is going to happen at some point and someone is going to get hurt,” he said.
Another increased expense to the city is Cumberland County taxes. South Portland’s county tax bill will be more than $2 million in the new fiscal year, an increase of more than $24,000. That will add 1 cent to the tax rate.
Comments are no longer available on this story