4 min read

Backers of a casino referendum said they will appeal the Maine Ethics Commission’s decision that fined the group $12,500 for filing late campaign finance reports.

Kathryn Rolston, treasurer for Scarborough Village Partnership political action committee, the group the commission fined, said on Monday she will appeal the decision once she receives the commission’s formal report.

“I have not yet received the formal decision,” Rolston said via e-mail Monday. “I do expect to appeal.”

According to Paul Lavin, assistant director of the The Maine Commission on Governmental Ethics and Election practices, Rolston has 30 days to file an appeal in Kennebec County Superior Court in Augusta.

“That time period starts from the day she receives our formal decision,” Lavin said. “We expect that we’ll be sending her that decision this week.”

At a hearing March 26, The Maine Commission on Governmental Ethics and Election Practices ruled that the Scarborough Village Partnership political action committee violated ethics laws for registering and filing its campaign reports late with Scarborough Town Clerk Tody Justice.

Advertisement

Rolston filed financial disclosure forms Oct. 24, the date Justice had told the PAC was the deadline. The law had changed and Justice was unaware of the change, Wayne said. The reports were due Oct. 10.

Last week, Rolston e-mailed Justice asking for detailed documents regarding all correspondence between the town, Casinos No! and Save Our Scarborough from August to October 2008.

Rolston is also requesting memoranda or other documents, including e-mails, between town employees or officials and any representatives of the Ethics Commission.

“I know that I tried to comply with the law, and that I followed precisely the instructions I received from the public officials in charge,” Rolston said in an e-mail Monday. “I filed precisely the reports they told me to file on the dates they said the reports were due. Participatory democracy is important, and it’s wrong to fine people for working hard on behalf of causes in which they truly believe.”

Justice declined to comment for this story.

Rolston said she also questions the honesty of her opponents during the campaign, specifically regarding two advertisements that appeared in local newspapers on Oct. 31.

Advertisement

During the March 26 hearing, Rolston said the Ethics Commission learned that CasinosNo! paid for two ads that appeared in local newspapers that listed Save Our Scarborough as the entity that paid for the ads.

While that isn’t illegal according to Jonathan Wayne, executive director of the Ethics Commission, it is misleading and dishonest to the voters, Rolston said.

Rolston said she understands the Ethics Commission couldn’t levy a fine against CasinosNo! or Save Our Scarborough, but that failure to list who paid for the ad misled voters.

“There was no transparency as to who paid for ads for the Scarborough group,” Rolston said. “The voters had no access to that information before they went to the polls.”

Scarborough Downs officials had proposed adding slots to the track as part of a $200 million commercial and residential development that would have given the town a center and $8 million in annual revenues.

Pitched by Connecticut developer Gene Beaudoin, the proposal to develop 535 acres owned by the track lost by just 239 votes. It was backed by Penn National Gaming Inc., which spent $135,000 in support of the proposal, according to the PAC’s campaign finance reports.

Advertisement

According to Wayne, Casinos No! paid for half of one ad and paid entirely for the other ad. Both ads read, “Paid for by Save Our Scarborough,” and totaled about $7,500, Wayne said.

Dennis Bailey, spokesman for Casinos No!, said his group and Save Our Scarborough didn’t intentionally try to mislead voters, and that the ads appeared with the understanding that Save Our Scarborough would pay back Casinos No! for the ads.

“I think the intent was that they were going to raise money to pay for those ads, and I don’t think they raised enough money,” Bailey said. “There might’ve been some costs that we had shared or that we picked up costs for.”

Rolston and Scarborough Village Partnership said they also were disappointed the Ethics Commission did not fine Save Our Scarborough or Casinos No! for failing to file on time an amended registration form disclosing its support of Save Our Scarborough, a requirement of Maine’s campaign finance law.

According to Wayne, the commission did find that Casinos No! violated the law, but chose not to levy a fine against that PAC.

“A majority of the commissioners felt that sending copies to the town clerk of their updated forms was adequate enough, which is why we didn’t levy a fine,” Wayne previously said.

That, Rolston said, concerned her because she was heavily penalized for filing late.

“The Ethics Commission’s purported concern was in transparency of the backers of the racino campaign, and for the potential harm to the voting public if such information were not available,” Rolston said. “Although I filed the PAC registration form late due to my own ignorance of PAC requirements, the information was filed. Casinos No! never complied with the requirement and got a free pass from the commission.”

Comments are no longer available on this story