4 min read

WESTBROOK –The city of Westbrook has taken the first steps to deal with a potential lawsuit from a local man injured in an encounter with a police department parking enforcement and animal control officer in 2009.

According to a notice of claim filed with the city, Daniel Casale, 49, of Mechanic Street, is seeking $1.4 million in damages from an Aug. 12, 2009, incident on West Pleasant Street.

The claim states Casale was out walking his dog when the officer stopped and questioned him. The officer eventually frisked Casale and found him in possession of scheduled drugs, according to the claim.

During the search, Casale’s dog started to walk into traffic and Casale tried to stop it. According to the claim, the officer “forcibly slammed” Casale against a police vehicle, “hard enough to fracture three bones in his right orbital socket and other vertebrae in his neck.”

Casale had to be taken to Mercy Hospital for treatment and when police returned his dog to his wife, “they told her that he had fallen,” the claim states.

The claim, filed with the city in September 2009 by attorney Robert Levine of Portland, provides notice that a lawsuit may be pending. It states Casale’s injuries from the incident included three broken bones around his right eye socket, a broken neck, pain and suffering, emotional distress and “possible permanent impairment.”

Advertisement

The city took the first steps recently to begin handling the potential litigation. On Jan. 3, the City Council gave a first reading to authorize paying a $5,000 deductible to the city’s previous insurance carrier, Maine Municipal Association Risk Management Services.

City Administrator Jerre Bryant said the insurance carrier is handling the case because it involves a monetary claim. He said the deductible is for “defense and indemnification.” Once the insurance company began incurring legal costs, it billed the city, he said.

The city’s insurance rates could go up if dealing with this matter becomes too costly, he said.

The company no longer insures the city, but, Bryant said, it is handling this case because it insured the company when the claim was filed. There has been no action on the issue until now.

“Normally (claims) move more quickly than this,” Bryant said.

A clerk at Cumberland County Superior Court said this week that no lawsuits have been filed in the case.

Advertisement

Casale’s attorney declined to comment, stating nothing has been finalized in writing yet.

A police report on the incident tells a different story about the encounter, which involved former parking and animal control officer Adam Farrington.

Farrington’s report states he was on patrol on Aug. 12, 2009, when he noticed Casale walking a pug that had no state license. As he went to approach Casale, a man on a motorcycle stopped on the side of the road and handed Casale something in exchange for cash, the report said.

The report said Casale hid the item in a plastic bag meant for dog waste and when Farrington questioned him about his dog’s status, he “was very agitated and was trying to walk away.”

When probed about the man on the motorcycle, Casale told Farrington he just had to give the man some money, but he didn’t know the man’s name. The police report indicates police later identified the man, but his name was redacted from the report.

During the conversation, according to Farrington, Casale tried to shove something into the back of his pants. Farrington said he received permission to check Casale, and when he did, found Casale in possession of one Ritalin tablet, a small drug fold containing a white powdery substance and a prescription pill bottle with Clonazepam.

Advertisement

At that point dispatchers alerted Farrington there was a warrant for Casale’s arrest. Farrington wrote that Casale attempted to pull away and kick him when told he was under arrest, and yelled out, “you need to catch my dog.”

The struggle continued until Farrington grabbed Casale, who is listed at 6 feet, 2 inches tall and 213 pounds, by the arm and did a leg sweep to take him to the ground, the report states.

“Both Mr. Casale and I went to the ground simultaneously. I received minor injuries to my hands as a result of trying to restrain him. While falling to the ground Mr. Casale accidentally struck his head on the pavement which caused him to stop resisting,” Farrington wrote.

Other police and rescue crews then responded to the scene. According to the report, poison control positively identified the drugs as Ritalin and 12 Clonazepam pills, while a field test on the white powder identified it as cocaine.

Police charged Casale with misdemeanors of unlawful possession of a scheduled drug and refusing to submit to arrest. A spokeswoman for the district attorney’s office said Casale pleaded guilty in January 2010 and received seven days in jail.

Casale could not be reached for comment.

Advertisement

Bryant said there were no other excessive force lawsuits filed against the city in the past five years. He described the allegations as serious, but said it is “absolutely not” a “red flag” because of the infrequency of such allegations.

“If these occurred with any frequency it would be a very serious issue,” he said.

Bryant said the city proactively addresses potential problems through its hiring, screening and management practices. Training also helps prevent such situations, he said.

“Things happen. We employ 40 or so human beings in that department,” he said.

Farrington is no longer with the department, having resigned in May, Bryant said. He declined to comment further.

Comments are no longer available on this story