9 min read

A rich aroma of newly ground coffee beans and fresh-baked muffins fills the air as the morning rush of customers enters the modern, brightly colored coffee shop filled with eclectic furniture and bold, floor-to-ceiling art.

Behind the counter, a woman wearing roller skates and a friendly smile glides forward to the cash register, carrying a mug of just-brewed coffee for the next customer.

At Cia Cafe in South Portland, everyone is treated like family.

“It’s a family business,” said Jeannie Dunnigan, owner of Cia. “We make it fun, and we want everyone to be comfortable, whether you’re a local or from away.”

Making customers feel welcome is part of what sets three locally owned coffee shops – Cia, The Local Buzz in Cape Elizabeth and Scarborough Grounds on Route 1 – apart from the conventional, fast-food coffee franchises.

The independently owned coffee shops are making their mark in the local community by offering more than just a quick cup of joe.

Advertisement

In the Knightville neighborhood, Cia Cafe, which opened two years ago in March, is a destination for locals and visitors alike who crave a mug of hot, fresh-brewed coffee made with organic, fair trade beans and a cozy place to study or meet with friends. Located at 72 Ocean St., Cia is open seven days a week, from 7 a.m.-6 p.m.

Some Cia customers are also there to admire the local art featured on the walls or order some ice cream, said Dunnigan, a Massachusetts transplant who runs the store with her husband, Bill, and son, Robert.

Cia stands for coffee, ice cream and art. Every eight weeks, Cia has a new art exhibit, including some of Dunnigan’s own paintings. In addition to being a cafe?, Cia is an art gallery where patrons can attend receptions, listen to live music and meet the artists, Dunnigan said.

“There is always something on the walls here,” she said.

In 2012, the Dunnigans moved to Maine from Salisbury, Mass., where Jeannie taught art and created art programs for kids at the Boys and Girls Club of Lower Merrimack Valley.

At the time, the Knightville neighborhood “looked like a ghost town,” as a majority of the storefronts on Ocean Street were vacant, the roads were not paved and the 8-foot-wide sidewalks had not been built, said Dunnigan, who roller skates around the shop.

Advertisement

“I’m usually on roller skates,” she said, laughing. “No. 1, it makes it fun, and No. 2, it makes me taller. I roller-skated everywhere when I was a kid. I am in here all day on these awesome (concrete) floors. In the summertime, I skate everywhere. I go to the store, I go to the bank. I am pretty good at it.”

Dunnigan, who is in her 40s, said the neighborhood “was screaming for people like me to come in. I want to put Knightville on the map. I want this to be a world-famous destination, as foolish as that sounds.”

The neighborhood these days is booming. Joining the already established condos, homes and restaurants is an art studio, Mainely Labs, opened in August 2014 across the street from Cia by local painter Jim Williams. In January 2014, another artist, Alaina Marie Harris, opened Alaina Marie, a couple doors down, where she sells her handmade clutches repurposed from lobsterman’s bait bags.

Knightville is “becoming a desirable neighborhood,” said Dunnigan. “Many people are starting to realize this is an awesome destination.”

Cia’s menu includes Wicked Joe coffee from Topsham, fresh-baked bread from Sorella’s Bakehouse in Portland and ice cream from Smiling Hill Farm in Westbrook.

“You’d be surprised how many Mainers like ice cream in the winter,” said Dunnigan.

Advertisement

Cia also sells baked goods such as cookies, muffins and scones, including a variety of gluten-free options, from Standard Baking Co. in Portland, Mainly Grains Bakers in South Portland and Bam Bam Bakery in Portland.

When making the coffee, Cia uses “the latest in brew technology,” she said. “It doesn’t cook the coffee; it keeps it fresh, hot and at the perfect temperature. We’ve invested a lot of time, energy, money and resources into learning all we can about brewing the perfect cup of coffee.”

Cia serves around 180-200 people a day. About 175 of Cia’s daily customers are coffee drinkers.

“Everything we make is all homemade or is local,” she said.

“We are very passionate about everything that we serve,” said Dunnigan. “It’s like if you were at home and wanted a nice sandwich made by your mom or grandmother.”

Elaine Farrugia, a South Portland resident and a regular customer of Cia Cafe?, said unlike other chain coffee shops, she does not feel rushed at Cia. She also likes admiring the artwork, and having the option to buy locally made gifts.

Advertisement

“It’s a good place to meet other people and talk, and you can stay as long as you want,” she said. “I like being able to hang out. It’s casual.”

Beth Penny, another South Portland resident, said she had a great first impression with Cia about a month ago when she learned it carries almond milk. She now plans to grab a toasted marshmallow latte at Cia at least twice a week, she said. She also likes the art aspect.

Penny was particularly impressed with how Cia remained open during one of the first major snowstorms this winter, when most of the other Knightville stores closed. For Penny, going to Cia is not a matter of convenience.

“I make an effort to come here,” she said. “It’s hip.”

The Local Buzz

About 10 minutes south of Cia, a coffeehouse, bar and bistro in Cape Elizabeth is living up to its name. Since The Local Buzz opened almost five years ago, it has become, in essence, “a community gathering place,” serving coffee, breakfast, lunch and, more recently, dinner, said owner Jamie Wagner.

Advertisement

Wagner, an attorney, started the Buzz because, at the time, Cape Elizabeth did not have a place to get a decent cup of coffee, he said.

“It was something I wanted to bring to town,” said Wagner of his business located at 327 Ocean House Road, at the Pond Cove Shopping Center. It’s the only year-round business in Cape Elizabeth dedicated to serving freshly brewed coffee and espresso daily, he added.

But the Buzz is not your typical, cookie-cutter coffee shop. According to Wagner, the Buzz is modeled after a coffeehouse, bar and lounge, Tryst, in Washington, D.C., where he lived before moving back to Maine in 2006. The Buzz also offers beer, wine and liquor in addition to its high-quality coffee selection. It is open Mondays, Tuesdays and Wednesdays from 6:30 a.m.-5 p.m., Thursdays and Fridays from 6:30 a.m.-9 p.m., Saturdays from 7 a.m.-6 p.m., and Sundays from 8 a.m.-2 p.m.

It’s a place where people like to unwind and socialize after school or work, Wagner said.

“It’s a great local resource,” said Cape Elizabeth resident A.J. Curran, a frequent customer.

The Buzz carries products by Portland companies including Coffee by Design, Tandem Coffee Roasters, Standard Baking Co., Shields Meat and Produce in Kennebunk and several Maine breweries.

Advertisement

The open-concept coffeehouse setting attracts morning business meetings, a place for students to plug in their laptops and study, and a venue for special occasions such as birthday parties, said Wagner.

While the Buzz gives off a warm, cozy vibe, the high, black ceilings, dark wooden furniture and numerous electrical outlets lend a utilitarian-type atmosphere.

“For some people, this is literally their office,” Wagner said.

The shop also is known for hosting live music on Fridays and other events in the evening that attract anywhere from 80-100 people. Offering a community gathering place like the Buzz was one of the most important elements of opening the business in Cape Elizabeth, said Wagner.

According to Wagner, the name, “The Local Buzz,” is a triple entendre, which stands for caffeine, alcohol and conversation.

“We wanted a place where people weren’t staring at a screen, but talking face to face and engaging with each other,” he said.

Advertisement

Local teacher David Shields, a daily patron, said the ambiance and friendly staff are what attracts him to the coffee shop.

“I like the atmosphere,” he said. “I sink right into the couch. I feel comfortable here.”

“It’s a comfortable location to come hang out with friends and have a cup of coffee or beer,” added Matt Dickinson, a barista, cook and bartender at the Buzz. “Or if you need (to get) work done, it’s a nice, cozy environment to sit for a couple hours. On nights when there’s music, if the band has a following, you can barely walk around in here.”

In the last couple of years the Buzz has expanded its menu and now serves a variety of sandwiches, wraps and burgers made with local meats. But the biggest selling item has always been the coffee.

“I can’t count how many pots of coffee I’ve made in my lifetime,” said Dickinson.

Scarborough Grounds

Advertisement

Fifteen minutes west, another coffee shop is buzzing. On Route 1 in Scarborough, across from the town’s municipal building and high school, the family-owned Scarborough Grounds cafe and eatery serves coffee, espresso, freshly made sandwiches, salads, soups and baked goods.

But what makes it unique is the location, said owner Jon Gates, former owner of Java Net Cafe in Portland, which closed in August 2009.

“We felt like there was a demand for a place like Scarborough Grounds in this area,” he said.

Scarborough Grounds opened in October 2009. In its sixth year, the business is “full steam ahead,” said Gates.

Gates said many patrons are giving up supporting chain coffee shops and starting to buy local. In addition to the businesspeople who frequent Scarborough Grounds for an afternoon pick-me-up and free WiFi, the bulk of his business is local students and commuters.

“There’s a wide range of people coming through our doors,” he said.

Advertisement

Scarborough Grounds is open Monday through Friday, 6 a.m.-5 p.m., Saturday from 7 a.m.-4 p.m., and Sunday from 7 a.m-2 p.m.

For local high school students Kristen Murray and Hannah Snyder, Scarborough Grounds is convenient, warm and welcoming. They also like its selection of fresh food items, from an egg and cheese breakfast sandwich to a curry chicken salad wrap.

When it comes to the coffee, “it’s higher quality, richer, stronger,” said Snyder. “We love coming here.”

The bustling coffee shop prides itself on serving quality food and beverages and for having excellent customer service. According to Gates, Scarborough Grounds was the only coffee shop of its kind on Route 1 until Starbucks opened about a year ago.

The cafe and eatery serves freshly roasted Maine coffee from Carpe Diem Roasting Co. in North Berwick, does catered lunches and has a drive-through.

Through the years, Gates has debated whether to close the drive-through to foot traffic only during the warmer months and offer ice cream. Patrons would then be able to enjoy their treats outside on the Scarborough Grounds patio, Gates said.

Advertisement

Even though the drive-through is a popular feature, many people would rather park their cars and come inside and stay a while, he said.

“People identify with my staff. They’re regulars,” he said.

South Portland resident Terri Bellas said she likes having the option to sit on comfortable furniture, drink her tea or coffee, read a magazine or socialize at her own pace.

“It’s relaxed,” she said. “Especially with this weather, it’s the kind of place to hang around, and talk and read.”

Jeannie Dunnigan is the owner of Cia Café in the Knightville neighborhood of South Portland. Her shop, as well as The Local Buzz in Cape Elizabeth and Scarborough Grounds in Scarborough, have become year-round community gathering spots, providing not only food and drink but also an attractive space for locals to socialize. Staff photo by Kayla J. CollinsThe Local Buzz barista Matt Dickinson hands a coffee to Cape Elizabeth resident and regular patron David Shields.Cia Cafe in South Portland features bright and colorful paintings as part of an eight-week rotating exhibit.Jon Gates, owner of Scarborough Grounds, pours a cup of coffee at the shop, located on Route 1.Staff photos by Kayla J. Collins

Comments are no longer available on this story