3 min read

A question that was once common in grocery store checkout lines often goes unasked nowadays: Paper or plastic? If customers don’t express a preference, grocery checkers will quickly stick the milk, bread, potato chips and soda in plastic bags and send them on their way.

That’s because, while most grocery stores like to offer what’s seen as the environmentally conscious alternative, many are bowing under the financial reality that plastic bags come at about a quarter of the cost of their paper counterparts. Reusable bags, on the other hand, are by far the cheapest alternative for everyone – the store, the consumer and the environment.

That’s why a recent proposal from the chairman of the Legislature’s Natural Resources Committee, Rep. Ted Koffman, D-Bar Harbor, makes a lot of sense. Koffman wants to place a 20 cent fee on plastic bags, which could be spent educating the public on the need to reduce the number of plastic bags in the environment and on offering incentives to consumers who choose reusable bags.

More than 380 billion plastic bags, sacks and wraps are consumed in the United States each year, according to the Environmental Protection Agency. The county goes through 100 billion plastic shopping bags each year, according to the Center for Policy Alternatives, a progressive lobbying group based in Washington, D.C.

But we don’t need statistics to tell us we use a lot of plastic bags. Most of us see an unhealthy portion of them every day – balled up and stuffed into a larger plastic bag hanging from one of the hooks in the pantry or crammed in a kitchen drawer, waiting for the next time Fido needs to go for a walk.

It is for this reason that representatives from the plastics industry argue that all this plastic waste isn’t such a bad thing. It can be reused – to carry our lunches to work and line the wastebaskets in our bathrooms. The problem with this argument is that once these bags are used a second time, they are thrown away.

Advertisement

No one wants to take to work the next day the bag that accompanied Fido on his walk. How many people fold up the bag they used to carry their lunch and put it in their pocket at the end of the day? Probably very few. Those who do have an even greater challenge keeping up with the number of bags they bring home from the grocery store each week. That bag hanging in the pantry just seems to swell.

Plastic bags can be recycled, but few are – only about 5 percent of the 100 billion used in the U.S. each year. Maine grocery stores are already required to provide a place to recycle bags, but few people know that and even fewer people take advantage of the drop-off bins.

The remaining 95 percent end up in our landfills, or worse yet, our streets, rivers and lakes. They blow in the breeze through our yards and parks, until they catch on a fence or tree limb, waving at us like a flag raised to remind us of all the waste we produce. Eventually, in as little as months or as much as hundreds of years, the bags decompose, leaving tiny toxic bits in our soils and streams.

While 20 cents a bag sounds like a lot, particularly as you try to jam another one into that kitchen drawer, the cost of failing to change our habits is much greater.

Brendan Moran, editor

Comments are no longer available on this story