For 40 years, Rudy’s of the Cape has been the place for locals and out-of-towners alike to grab a sandwich, a “lobstah” roll or a bowl of chowder, and discuss the news of the town and the world.
Taken over by Ron and Mary Page in 2003, the Ocean House Road eatery has maintained its name, its flair and its character. Business is doing well, and Mary Page says Rudy’s simply can’t keep up with the times if it can’t expand its hours of operation and build a patio to increase its seating capacity.
Tough luck, says the Cape Elizabeth town attorney.
Rudy’s is in a resource protection district, and according to attorney Michael Hill, that means the Pages can’t expand either the seating capacity or the hours.
To Mary Page, that’s ludicrous. Appearing before last week’s Cape Elizabeth Town Council meeting, Page said she’s already gotten state approval to expand and spent more than $10,000 and months on the process, only to receive Hill’s legal opinion.
“If I would have known this, I never would have started this process,” she said.
Page said it would be difficult for enterprises in the area to stay in business if they can’t expand and adapt to changing times. Places like Rudy’s, she said, are more than stores; they’re community gathering places and part of the glue that holds the town together. If they were to go out of business – or relocate to the town’s designated commercial spaces – they would no longer serve that purpose.
“You can’t have a neighborhood tavern and you can’t have a neighborhood (store) that is not located in a neighborhood,” she told the Town Council.
Page did not return several calls seeking comment after the meeting.
The Pages aren’t alone. Some town officials wonder if the ordinance protecting town’s natural resources doesn’t go too far, and might end up being detrimental to the town’s character. Many of the other businesses in the area are also nonconforming and “cannot be expanded in any way, shape or manner,” according to Town Manager Michael McGovern.
“Businesses need to evolve,” he acknowledged. “We really need to look at the (zone where Rudy’s is located), if it’s a viable zone if everything in it is nonconforming.”
At his recommendation, the Town Council has referred the matter to the Planning Board. Should that board suggest zoning changes to allow Rudy’s and other businesses in the area to expand, the matter would likely come back before the Council this summer.
Another business that could come under scrutiny is Jordan’s Lawn and Garden Center. In operation since 1972, Jordan’s was recently taken over by Carl Pearson and his family, who, according to Pearson, have a lease with an option to purchase the buildings and property.
One of Pearson’s sons is a licensed real estate agent. He’s offering services at the Jordan’s location.
“Another son does welding, so we’re going to offer his light-duty welding,” Pearson said. Pearson said he hasn’t heard anything from town officials, but he was concerned enough to address the Town Council last week and recommend a zoning change.
“We’re not adding anything to the footprint – it’s just going to be within the existing structure,” he said in an interview after the Town Council meeting, arguing that his business will not be changing from the activities already permitted.
“… They’ve been welding here since 30 years ago. I found out from a local source that the gentleman that held this place – Gilly Jordan – he was not a licensed broker,” but he did conduct real estate transactions, Pearson said.
“Real estate’s been transacted out of here for 30 years,” Pearson said. “Nothing’s changing. The Planning Board, they just shrugged their shoulders and said, ‘We’re not really sure.’ They haven’t said anything either way.”
“I think that common sense would rule out in the long run,” he added.
However, he said, several other businesses in the area could be affected should the town take the hard line and refuse any expansion whatsoever.
Although the Town Council could have revised the ordinance at Page’s request, Councilor Paul McKenney said it’s rare – almost unheard of – to do so.
“It would be very rare for the council to take unilateral action without … (consulting) the appropriate board or commission,” he said. “I think we’re asking the Planning Board to look at the entire (zoning) district to see what proposed changes they would refer back to the council. It’s really in the Planning Board’s hands at this point.”
Comments are no longer available on this story