The South Portland City Council voted Monday night to send the city’s first beekeeping ordinance back to workshop for further review after it created an angry buzz across Maine.
The Council’s flight from establishing a local beekeeping ordinance happened after members received several letters and e-mails from hobbyists who say that Maine already has a state Beekeepers Association that educates the public, registers keepers and offers a comprehensive list of best practices for people to follow.
The letter writers complained that local regulations, fees and a permitting process will discourage back yard honey bee operations and make them too costly.
“Why is a nonresident getting involved in South Portland’s affairs?” hobbyist Roy Cronkhite of Livermore Falls wrote to several residents and officials.
“I wish that I did not have to, but this issue transcends South Portland. If the city enacts an ordinance, will it set off a chain reaction with other cities from the greater Portland area or other Maine cities?” he wrote.
“As a member of the Maine State Beekeepers Association, I feel that it is my duty to, respectfully, pass along my feelings and any pertinent information.”
Cronkhite and other beekeepers are urging South Portland officials to seek assistance on beekeeping guidelines from the state organization before passing any ordinance.
The Council also received several letters from South Portland residents urging members to support local beekeeping operations.
“Although I am not a beekeeper, I enjoy the value that honey bees bring to me,” resident Walter Pellock wrote to the Council.
“I benefit from having honey bees in my yard, as I know they are good for the environment and our food supply. As a 28-year homeowner in South Portland, I would appreciate it, if the city of South Portland would not interfere in any way with honeybees or beekeepers.”
The swarm of support for beekeepers is a reaction to the Council’s effort to regulate backyard bee operations in South Portland.
Patricia Doucette, who directs Code Enforcement, said she does not know how many people keep bees in South Portland.
But members of the state beekeepers group say they know of only two in the city.
A resident’s complaint last summer about one of those backyard beekeeping operations, located at a residence on Robert Mills Road, prompted the City Council to propose rules for raising bees.
According to the city, Omid Ghayebi, was keeping five hives in his yard last summer, when a couple complained that bees were congregating at their pool.
Ghayebi did not return calls for comment.
The ordinance that Doucette and former City Attorney Mary Kahl created limits beekeeping to hobbyists, meaning that commercial honey-making operations would be banned.
The beekeeping ordinance also sets up an annual $25 registration fee.
It limits the number of colonies that a homeowner can have based on property size. For example, a beekeeper can keep up to two colonies on a quarter acre of land or less.
The ordinance details the types of hives and requires that colonies have a queen.
Under the ordinance, beekeepers must provide the insects with a constant source of water, since they will fly to swimming pools and even outdoor pet dishes, if fresh water is not provided by the beekeeper.
The ordinance was crafted from a similar one that Westbrook adopted, city officials said.
But Cronkhite, the bee hobbyist from Livermore Falls, said the beekeeper who faced complaints has since registered his hives with the state Beekeepers’ Association and is getting support on best practices.
“He also found out about the Cumberland County Beekeepers Association and is seeking their guidance. These same folks would be glad to assist the city and the concerned neighbor,” Cronkhite concluded.
Council members acknowledged Monday night they need more information and discussions before holding a public hearing and adopting an ordinance.
“I have further questions,” Councilor Maxine Beecher said. “If we do this, let’s do it right,” she said referring to the ordinance.
One of Ghayebi’s neighbors also wrote to the council in support of his backyard operation.
Residents William R. Syska and Meredith Blethen, who live on Roberts Mill Road, said they support “urban beekeeping” and described honeybees as “beneficial and non-aggressive.”
“The proposed beekeeping ordinance is so rigid that if it is adopted it will force our beekeeping neighbor to abandon his hobby,” the couple wrote.
“The ordinance also poses prohibitive and we think unreasonable fines of up to $1,000 per violation, per day.”
They urged Council members to vote against the ordinance, as it is currently written.
Councilor Tom Blake noted later that he is concerned about the city drawing up an ordinance based on a single complaint.
“I sell firewood and Christmas trees from trees I raise,” Blake said. “I would be irritated if the city stopped me from doing that. Why should beekeepers be treated differently?”
South Portland also has a long and storied history of beekeepers. One of its most famous residents, Fred Hale, was an avid beekeeper.
Known as America’s oldest living man, Hale credited his longevity to eating honey and bee pollen. Hale’s honey came from bees he kept as a hobbyist.
Hale died in 2004 at the age of 113. Web sites on Hale contain sweet memories of his beekeeping and honey making in South Portland.
“I knew Fred when we both lived in South Portland, Maine, in the late seventies,” wrote former resident Richard Johnson in 2007. “He sparked my interest in beekeeping. I visited him quite a few times and he talked about beekeeping mostly.”
Comments are no longer available on this story