3 min read

WINDHAM – The Windham Town Council, unwilling to impose a ban on plastic shopping bags for fear of potential legal and economic ramifications, will instead draft a resolution to lobby the state Legislature to impose the ban statewide.

The plastic bag ban, proposed last month by Windham Middle School eighth-grader Sierra Yost, would prohibit stores from giving customers single-use bags and would require stores to impose a fee on customers who request non-recyclable bags.

Yost, who addressed the council in April with a 10-minute presentation detailing plastic bags’ effect on the environment, is hoping the ban would encourage the use of reusable bags.

“It’s only $1 for a nice, reusable bag and I think everyone has that to spare,” Yost said in urging the council to adopt the ban.

The council, led by Councilor Tommy Gleason, praised Yost’s passion for the environment, but, on the advice of the town lawyer, Ken Cole III, who was asked to render his opinion on a ban, said the ban and fee would have ramifications that would affect jobs and businesses.

Gleason said paper bags, which would also be banned, are the lifeblood of Maine paper mill towns, which were severely impacted when companies such as Sears and J.C. Penney stopped printing their large catalogs.

Advertisement

Careful not to stunt her activist spirit, Gleason said, “Not that you’re wrong, but there are ramifications for what we do…every action has a reaction…and we have to minimize that reaction as best as we can,” Gleason said, regarding the potential economic impact a bag ban would have in Maine.

Yost and others spoke again on the matter Tuesday night, urging councilors to be leaders in the effort, and not to take the easy way out by claiming the town would open itself to lawsuits.

“We have a responsibility to support our town, our earth and home planet,” Yost said. “We’ve put convenience before responsibility for far too long.”

The girl’s father, Rick Yost, said the town should be able to craft legislation “that would stand up to litigation. Dozens of towns across the country are choosing to do this. Windham, I would urge you to do the same.”

Martin Shuer, an independent candidate for Senate District 12, also urged the town to adopt an ordinance and set an example, alluding to the state’s motto, Dirigo, or, “I Lead.”

“We have an opportunity to lead and make a statement,” Shuer said, adding that businesses may save money by not having to pay for plastic bags.

Advertisement

Yost’s call for a bag ban has spread far and wide, soliciting an industry spokesman and lobbyist, Sara Vanderwood, to make an appearance at the meeting in hopes of heading off what could be Maine’s first town to impose a plastic-bag ban. Vanderwood, on staff as a lobbyist with Portland-based law firm Verrill Dana, spoke as a lobbyist for Hilex Poly, which is pushing a “Bag the Ban” campaign, in response to communities like Windham considering a fee or ban. Hilex Poly is a manufacturer of plastic bags that uses recycled plastic to make its bags.

Vanderwood said a tax on plastic bags or outright ban is a job killer, since more than 10,000 Americans are employed in the manufacture and recycling of plastic bags.

She also said a ban has reduced average incomes in areas where the ban is imposed and actually increases the overall amount of bags used when consumers aren’t given bags at a checkout. She claimed there was a 400 percent increase in the number of bags annually used in one community when customers had to buy plastic bags off the shelf.

Vanderwood also cited studies that say the hundreds of millions of reusable bags that have been recently introduced in America to replace the single-use plastic bags come from China and contain lead. She claims the reusable cloth bags can trap harmful bacteria as well, which can taint food.

The council requested the town manager to draft a resolution reflecting Yost’s call for a ban. It will deliberate on the language at its next meeting.

Comments are no longer available on this story