4 min read

Police union representatives are hoping a fact-finding session will end their nearly year-long dispute with the town of Cape Elizabeth over a sticking point in their contract negotiations – retirement benefits.

Lawyers for the town and the union, called the Cape Elizabeth Police Benevolent Association, will join a neutral party from the Maine Labor Relations Board Thursday, July 13, in deciding whether or not the union should receive the Maine State Retirement package they’ve been vying for in the past year.

Mark Dorval, president of the union, said the union is entering into these talks with an open mind, but their goal hasn’t changed. “We want what we’ve always wanted…state retirement,” said Dorval. The town left the Maine State Retirement System in 1994.

Town Manager Mike McGovern would not comment on the upcoming fact finding session because he said the Maine Labor Relations Board requested that both parties cease negotiating in the press.

“Negotiating in the press makes it that much harder for them to move from the position they’ve staked,” said Marc Ayotte, executive director of the Maine Labor Relations Board.

While the police want the town to buy them back into the Maine State Retirement plan with a 50-percent-pay pension after 25 years of service regardless of age, the town has offered the police an increase of 3 percent in their matching 401(a) pension plan.

Advertisement

After the second year of their three-year contract, the town would contribute 10 percent of their pay to a private account, where each employee makes personal investment decisions from more than a dozen possibilities.

Under this plan police department employees face penalties on benefits if they retire before age 59-and-a-half.

The union says, with Maine State Retirement, officers could retire earlier, making room for movement in the department while having an attractive recruiting tool because of its stability, but the town says the cost of buying back into the system is too expensive. It puts the investment risk onto the town rather than the employee, where it is now.

So, following a failed mediation in September, the union applied for a fact-finding session with the Maine Labor Relations Board.

Ayotte said that out of 100 disputes that went through the Labor Board last year 58 went to mediation and about 12 went on to fact finding. “They’re quite a ways down the road,” said Ayotte of the union and the town. “When you get this far down, there are very few issues separating the parties.”

Since last March, when the contract negotiations began, the majority of the kinks have been worked out of the contract, which expired June 30, 2005. Only unsettled retirement benefits keep the town and union from signing a new three-year contract.

Advertisement

“In some ways that makes it harder. If you have a lot of issues you can trade off,” said Ayotte.

However, fact-finding generally ends in a settlement, said Ayotte. Whether the town or union is favored, or there is a compromise, the dispute will most likely be resolved, he said.

Following the failed mediation, tension heightened between the union and town and the police have used several tactics to relay their message including refusing to shave and picketing town hall.

Following several volatile public comments from police, McGovern pulled himself out of talks and replaced himself with the town lawyer, who has dealt directly with the negotiations since then.

Dorval maintains the department is one of the few in the area that has requested state retirement but has been rejected.

With so many other departments buying into the Maine State Retirment system, Dorval said he hasn’t heard a valid argument for rejecting the union’s request. “I’m still waiting for the justification,” he said. “If it’s such a bad thing other municipalities wouldn’t be getting into it.”

Advertisement

South Portland, Yarmouth, Cumberland, Freeport and now Windham all offer their union some form of Maine State Retirement, according to the union. Westbrook police worked without a contract for three years fighting for Maine State Retirement and finally won it in a contract they agreed to this past October.

Though Dorval said the union still wants Maine State Retirement, he said if fact finding doesn’t favor the union, they are willing to reconsider their position. “What fact finding puts out everybody needs to take a hard look at,” said Dorval.

Fighting with the town and working without a contract for nearly a year has stressed the department and their morale. It’s time for it to end, he said.

“We need to get back to the way things were,” he said.

Mark Dorval

Comments are no longer available on this story