As we await our tax returns or prepare to file, let us consider the curious case of Michael Skarbinski, who is about to learn the hard way about the consequences of failing to claim income on his tax return.
Skarbinski, 48, and his wife, Elizabeth, 44, are facing up to three years in jail for asking to have all of their income taxes returned in each of the previous three years, by claiming zero taxable income on their tax forms, despite the fact that they made $142,000 in wages in 2007 alone.
However, Michael Skarbinski, a School Administrative District 61 director from Sebago, doesn’t believe he’s done anything wrong because, he says, no one is required to pay taxes on labor under the federal tax code.
The Skarbinskis are tax protestors, who generally fall into two categories – people who refuse to pay their taxes because they disagree with the government’s policies or people who refuse to pay their taxes because of an obscure argument about the tax code.
The Skarbinskis are clearly in the latter category, and they are far from alone. There is a long list of arguments about the tax code and a long list of people who have made them. Some argue, for example, that the federal income tax is unconstitutional because it is a “direct tax,” and the federal government has the authority to tax only states. Others argue the federal government can only tax income regulated by Congress, such as the sale of alcohol or tobacco or interstate commerce.
Michael Skarbinski argues that the tax code doesn’t allow for the taxation of wages, only profit from investments. He does pay property and sales taxes. Skarbinski says the tax code lists only certain categories that have to pay income taxes, including foreigners doing business in the United States, resident aliens and U.S. citizens doing business abroad, and he doesn’t fit into any of those categories.
Skarbinski’s argument and a couple dozen more are listed on the IRS Web site, www.irs.gov, along with the government’s arguments for why they are false, each of them buttressed by long lists of court decisions. He’s probably not willing to take the word of the IRS, though, and for that he will have to face the courts.
For those who might be thinking of following Skarbinski’s lead this tax season, we would recommend one of a number of different routes – a letter to the editor or, perhaps, a tax blog. While this country has a long history of civil disobedience as a method of protest, those who practice it have to be prepared to pay the potential penalty – prison. Because the Sarbinskis have five children, they probably don’t want to pay that price.
The courts should be lenient with them. Prison is too strong a penalty in this case. A fine would be more appropriate. Although choosing not to pay his taxes because of his disagreement with the government’s application of the tax code was in poor judgement, Skarbinski, who spoke to us in a lengthy interview, does seem to genuinely feel as though he’s doing what’s right – standing up for other taxpayers.
Despite that, he should step down from the School Board. The schools he is overseeing depend on the income taxes he is refusing to pay, and his decision that led the state to prosecute him could very well undermine the confidence of the constituents he needs to represent.
Brendan Moran, editor
Comments are no longer available on this story