After careful deliberation during the last several months the Firing Range Committee in Cape Elizabeth on Monday deemed the Spurwink Rod & Gun Club’s first renewal license application as complete.
During the three-hour meeting at Town Hall, the committee also voted 4-1, with member Cathy Kline opposed, to recommend that the Town Council approve the license application. Kline is a resident of Cross Hill Road, where a housing development abuts the Sawyer Road shooting range.
Kline said she believed the club’s shooting range evaluation that was included in the application wasn’t in-depth enough.
“I just don’t know if it addresses safety,” she said.
Nine residents whose homes abut the shooting range attended Monday’s meeting, but none spoke during the public comment period.
Since the mid-1990s, the shooting range has been the focus of noise and safety complaints by nearby Cross Hill Road neighbors. As a result, the town of Cape Elizabeth adopted its first-ever shooting range ordinance in March 2014 that requires both existing and new clubs in Cape Elizabeth to apply for a license annually.
The gun club turned in its license application for a second time on June 1.
Firing Range Committee members deemed the club’s application incomplete in early May after finding that at least seven separate items were missing or lacked detail, including proof of liability insurance, a thorough description of the firearms and ammunition used on the property, as well as a site plan showing the dwellings located within a half-mile of the shooting range.
Gun club members have spent the last year updating the shooting range in order to address ongoing noise and safety concerns. In addition to a professional safety evaluation the club had done on the shooting range in 2012, the town has ordered a second independent safety evaluation as part of the application process, which has not been completed yet.
Mark Mayone, former gun club president and member of the Firing Range Committee, said he thinks the club is being held to higher standards compared with other gun clubs in southern Maine, especially as it pertains to its safety.
“Every time we bring up the safety evaluation, within a week, the (range) changes again,” Mayone said. “It’s like asking for an occupancy permit when you’re halfway through the construction. Don’t get me wrong – I am all for it. But you have to realize, we are evaluating (a construction project) that is half done.”
While the Firing Range Committee is recommending the license application for approval, it is also planning to present several findings – including that the range design provides for reasonable shot containment – and a few recommendations to the council for consideration.
Among other items, the committee recommends that the Town Council asks the town’s independent safety evaluator to comment on the design phasing of the range and whether it meets National Rifle Association standards, and that it look into the feasibility of changing the club’s hours of operation on weekends to possibly address noise and safety concerns.
“There is no safety aspect to reducing the hours at Spurwink Rod & Gun Club,” said resident and gun club member Andy Tabor.
“When a range is used as intended, we have 100 percent shot containment,” Mayone said. “This range, as intended, is perfectly safe.”
Firing Range Committee Chairwoman Caitlin Jordan, who is also a member of the Town Council, said the council likely won’t review and discuss the gun club’s license application until July or August.
The council will likely not schedule a public hearing and final vote on the application until the independent safety evaluation is completed at the range and presented to council members later this summer, she added.
Residents of Cross Hill Road in Cape Elizabeth, whose homes abut the Spurwink Rod & Gun Club on Sawyer Road, sit in the audience during the Firing Range Committee meeting at the Town Hall Monday. None of the residents spoke during the public comment period. Staff photo by Kayla J. Collins
Comments are no longer available on this story