An independent engineer has concluded there are no significant problems with the Scarborough High School construction project.
The entire review of the construction project cost the town $113,000, according to the school district.
“Regular maintenance of the school building should provide security for the town of Scarborough and its taxpayers that the Scarborough High School addition and renovation is indeed a sound and long lasting academic institution,” said Po Shang Chen, of C&C Consulting, the company that performed the review.
The report was the final step in a lengthy review process of the high school that was started last March when Town Councilors Jeffrey Messer and Robert Patch raised concerns about the project. Messer did not return calls seeking comment this week.
C&C Consulting reviewed the $27 million high school project at the request of the Scarborough Code Enforcement Department, which felt it did not have the necessary expertise to review certain areas of the project. C&C’s work focused on 10 areas.
In the final report, Chen said four of the areas “had some minor inconsistencies with the requirements of the applicable project building codes or contract documents,” but had no objections to the construction of the remaining areas.
To ensure that the four areas in question do not become a problem in the future, Chen recommended that the school department perform regular maintenance and inspections of the area after hazardous weather events.
“We feel vindicated having now received the town’s final report,” said Norm Justice, the owner’s representative for the project and district facilities manager. “We were confident all along that the work was progressing as it should be.”
Justice said the district performs regular maintenance on all of its buildings and would be undertaking the recommended actions as part of its normal course.
School board Chairman Robert Mitchell said he was happy with the report’s final results. He said the lesson he took from the whole experience is the value of communication. The project remains on schedule and is expected to be completed in the spring.
“I think the taxpayers should be pleased with the end result,” he said.
School board member Dianne Messer said the final report made her feel better about the project, but questioned what is “regular maintenance” verses what the district is now doing. “I’m glad the structural integrity is going to hold-up,” she said.
Justice felt the $113,000 could have been spent in a better way. “It’s unfortunate; that money could have been spent to enhance the facilities or improve the educational system,” he said.
The $113,000 is the total cost for every service performed during the review, ranging from the cost of copies to attorney fees.
The largest expenditure was for Chen. The town initially approved spending $25,000 for his services, but once all of the work was done it totaled nearly $37,000. The reason for the increase was the additional site visits and reviews.
The second largest expenditure was $33,500 for Pizzagalli Construction, the contractor working on the school, for its work on the review. Harriman Associates, the project’s architects, also billed the district for a little more than $28,000.
Kevin Freeman, director of business development for Pizzagalli Construction, has stood behind his company’s work since questions were first raised about the quality of the construction work and said his opinion never changed.
“We stood behind our work right from the beginning,” he said. “We did what the school district and Harriman Associates asked us to do on the project.”
Freeman said the project was a challenge and his company performed well under the circumstances to complete the project on time and on budget. He said Pizzagalli responded to the concerns when they were raised and continued to do so during the entire process, but the questions kept coming.
“Our answers were never good enough,” he said. “Ultimately, what Dr. Chen said was what we said in March.”
Comments are no longer available on this story