Despite sagging morale over their lack of a contract, Cape police rallied for several sessions of picketing at Town Hall on Monday.
With signs reading “Honk to support your police” and “competitive retirement for cops,” officers picketed beside Town Hall hoping to raise awareness of the battle they’ve fought for better retirement benefits since last August.
All morning long, passing vehicles, including resident and town-owned vehicles, honked in support of the police. School busses, ambulances and public works trucks all demonstrated their support with a honk or two and sometimes a succession of honks.
Later that morning, Town Manager Mike McGovern asked town department heads to tell their employees that honking while driving a town-owned vehicle is an inappropriate display of a political position. “It’s no different than putting a Bush sticker on a municipal vehicle, you just don’t do it,” said McGovern.
Police argue that an officer’s tenure under their current retirement plan is too long. Serving on patrol up until you’re 60 is bad for the officer and the community they serve, they say.
However, McGovern said the picketing hasn’t convinced him. “How they think this is going to win retirement benefits, I don’t know,” he said.
The Cape Elizabeth Police Benevolent Association, which represents eight police officers, three sergeants and four dispatchers, has been without a contract since their prior three-year contract expired on June 30, 2005. Negotiations stalemated over retirement benefits in September after mediation, requested by police, failed.
The town offered a three percent increase in benefits over two years, upping their 401(a) plan from 7 to 10 percent of pay. But police say they want the town to buy them into the Maine State Retirement plan that allows them to retire after 25 years with 50 percent of pay, regardless of age. The town opted out of the Maine State Retirement System in 1994.
An 18-year veteran of the Old Orchard Beach police department, Scarborough resident Kevin Riordan picketed alongside Cape police early Monday morning. Old Orchard Beach offers a 25 years and two-thirds pay Maine State Retirement plan. Under Cape’s 401 (a) defined contribution plan, employees must wait until they are 60 to retire.
Riordan says 60 is too old for a police officer. “You don’t want 60 year-old cops. It’s a demanding job.”
In May, 59-year-old Vaughn Dyer will have spent 31 years with the Cape police. Dyer, who stayed with the state retirement plan initially offered by the town prior to 1994, could retire after 25 years of service, but only at the minimum age of 60. Dyer calls this the “worst, lousiest, cheapest plan,” available.
At nearly 60 years old, Dyer suffers from arthritis. After knee surgery for a torn meniscus, which Dyer surmises is an arthritis-related injury, he sometimes walks with a limp.
“How confident would you feel seeing a cop come limping up your driveway,” he asked.
Retired Cape officer Dick Lindsey said an officer should not serve into his 60s. Cape, as a small department, is especially disadvantaged because there are no desk jobs for older cops unsuitable for patrol, he said. In larger departments, older officers are often office bound, said Lindsey, but in Cape they’re still scheduled for patrol.
“Fifty, 55, you should be out of this job,” he said. And in larger departments, “probably by that time, you’re behind a desk somewhere,” but in Cape, Lindsey said, “they’re still working the road.”
Cape Elizabeth Police Benevolent Association President Mark Dorval said the plan the police want would allow for more movement within the department, opening up promotional positions, making the department more attractive for young recruits.
However, because the state plan is a defined benefit plan, it is riskier for the town, because retired officers are guaranteed a certain level of compensation regardless of the market. With a defined contribution plan such as the 401(a) now offered, the risk is on the employee, because the town will continue contributing only a certain percentage of pay.
Of eight neighboring towns comparable to Cape Elizabeth, five offer some form of the state retirement system.
Kevin Kennedy and Andrew Steindl were both hired by the Cape police in 1988. At that time, Maine State Retirement was the plan available to the department.
When the 401(a) option was offered in 1990, Steindl said he switched over because he could begin collecting benefits at 59-and-a-half years old. Though it was only a six-month difference from the 60-year minimum offered by state retirement system, Steindl switched. “That sounded better to me at the time,” he said.
Now though, Steindl and Kennedy want the opportunity to switch back.
The town’s refusal to buy them back into the system is frustrating and is draining the department’s morale, said Dorval.
Town Councilors David Backer and Anne Swift-Kayatta said other than one handwritten letter supporting the police, they haven’t received any public comment either supporting or opposing the police request to buy back into state retirement system.
McGovern said though there is little written comment, residents frequently tell him they oppose buying the police back into the state system. “This is what I get on the street; at the grocery store, at events,” he said.
The union has entered into fact-finding with town lawyer Linda McGill. Fact-finding is the follow-up step of negotiations when mediation fails. Town Manager Mike McGovern pulled himself from negotiations at the end of December following angry public comments from the union about the process.
Union members have said repeatedly the negotiation process has made them feel unappreciated and devalued. The process has diminished their respect for town leadership.
“We’re all proud to be police officers, but at this point we’re not proud to work for this town government,” said Kennedy.
Comments are no longer available on this story