Westbrook city councilors rebuked state legislators Monday, as they reluctantly gave preliminary approval to changes in the city’s sex offender ordinance, which was trumped by a new state law passed in June.
Two years ago, the City Council enacted one of the strictest ordinances in the state for establishing boundaries for where convicted sex offenders can live and work in Westbrook. However, state lawmakers decided to make restrictions more uniform throughout Maine’s municipalities by creating a law that prohibits sex offenders from living within 750 feet of schools or any public property primarily used by children. It also prevents local officials from making any more stringent rules.
Westbrook’s ordinance restricted any registered sex offender whose crime was committed against an individual under 18 from living or working within 2,500 feet of a school, child care center or home, park, playground, bowling alley or any other location frequented by children. The ordinance bars these sex offenders from the most densely populated residential and business districts in the city, including all of downtown.
Councilors Monday defended that ordinance and expressed their disapproval of the Legislature for seizing local control and gutting a law they worked hard to develop based on the needs of their city and its children.
Councilor Drew Gattine said the council’s unanimous vote in 2007 couldn’t convey how strongly each member of the board supported the city’s ordinance.
“We were one mind,” Gattine said. “Really what we’re left with is a shell. It’s disappointing and shameful what this has come to.”
Councilor John O’Hara said he, too, was “terribly, terribly disappointed in the legislative body.”
The state restrictions apply only to sex offenders who committed their crime against children under 15 years old, which O’Hara said, was essentially a move to “lower the bar for pedophilia to be committed.”
“That is a crime itself,” he said.
Both O’Hara and Council President Brendan Rielly drove home the fact that Westbrook councilors know the city better than any other officials.
“We’re pretty well represented on the registry,” Rielly said, and the council was justified in taking what he called “an aggressive but reasoned approach” to sex offender restrictions.
“I’m disgusted,” he said.
Rielly didn’t apologize for the fact that the ordinance, which was supported by the city’s police department, prohibited sex offenders from living or working in the vast majority of the city, save about 2 1/2 miles of Methodist Road, a half mile of Bridgton Road, a half mile of Duck Pond Road and two-thirds of a mile of Brook Street.
“If there was a way to legally do it, I would have banned it outright,” he said.
But legislators in favor of the law say statistics show that restricting where sex offenders live does not make children safer, but does the opposite.
As originally written, the bill, called An Act To Ensure a Uniform Comprehensive State Policy Regarding Residency Restrictions for Sex Offenders, sponsored by Sen. Anne Haskell, D-Portland, proposed no restrictions on where sex offenders could live. The bill that was eventually passed was a compromise among the Maine Municipal Association, the Maine Coalition Against Sexual Assault and the Department of Corrections.
In defense of the law, Haskell said in June, residency restrictions drive sex offenders underground making it harder to keep track of them. In addition, she said, strict ordinances create a false sense of security.
Even the Maine Coalition Against Sexual Assault doesn’t support residency restrictions imposed by state or local officials. Executive Director Elizabeth Ward Saxl said this spring, her organization believes that should be the job of the probation officers and done on a case-by-case basis, rather than by law.
Both senators who represent Westbrook, Philip Bartlett and Joseph Brannigan, voted in favor of the bill, which passed 22-12. The bill passed through the house without a vote, and Reps. Tim Driscoll, D-Westbrook, and Ann Peoples, D-Westbrook, both said there was no debate on the floor.
However, Peoples said Tuesday, she would be willing to sponsor a new bill next legislative session if the city councilors were interested in bringing one forward.
“There is no law that we make that we cannot change,” Peoples said. “I’m prepared to help in any way I can.”
Rielly said that would definitely be something he’d like to pursue. When the state law was passed this spring, Rielly said, he approached City Solicitor Bill Dale to see if there was anyway the city could bring a lawsuit against the state.
Dale said Monday he advised councilors that such a lawsuit would have “absolutely no chance of success.”
The council is scheduled to give final approval to the changes in the ordinance, in order to comply with the state law, at a meeting in September, which is when the law goes into effect throughout the state. Though the law will supersede any town or city ordinances that are more restrictive, it is not mandatory and does not automatically apply to every municipality.
Meanwhile, Police Chief Bill Baker assured councilors Monday that his department will do the best it can with the tools it has and that children are safer in Westbrook, he believes, than they are in most of the rest of the state.
“I think that with competent police work, we’ll continue to be ahead of the curve,” Baker said.
Comments are no longer available on this story