FREEPORT – Once thought to be closed for good after the death of one of the longtime owners last year, Frosty’s Donuts, a mainstay for decades on Brunswick’s Maine Street, has not only come back under new ownership, but also is expanding to Freeport later this summer.
Frosty’s will move into the former jewelry store behind the Freeport Historical Society at 45 Main St., and owner Nels Omdal said that he hopes work on the space would be done in time for an Aug. 1 opening. The Freeport Town Council approved the application for a victualer’s license on July 10.
It’s a hectic time for Omdal, as he and his wife (and Frosty’s co-owner), Shelby St. Andre, are working on the new Freeport shop and the Brunswick shop, plus they also welcomed a new baby earlier this summer.
Omdal, 34, a Brunswick resident, and his wife purchased Frosty’s in January. He said they were longtime customers of the shop and hated to see it close.
“In a joking way, I had always talked about owning Frosty’s,” said Omdal, who had run an Italian restaurant when he was younger, but had no real experience running a doughnut shop.
“We drove by one day and had a gut feeling,” Omdal said about the decision to buy the shop.
He said that they met with the real estate agent and owner Bob Frost, who closed the shop when his wife died in July 2011, on a Saturday, put in an offer on a Tuesday and had the shop under contract the next day.
Keeping everything the same was important to the new owners. Omdal said he worked with Frost’s son, who had baked there for a number of years, and Omdal is now making the same doughnuts that Frosty’s customers enjoyed for years.
Now, with the Brunswick location going strongly, Omdal said, he and his wife believe the time is right to expand, which had always been in the back of their minds anyway. Freeport was a primary target right from the start.
St. Andre identified the location behind the Freeport Historical Society on Main Street as a good one for a future Frosty’s, especially with the building’s highly visible location, and even more importantly, available parking close by the entrance.
“We knew if and when we were going to expand, we would stay close,” Omdal said. “And my wife saw this location in Freeport and said, ‘This would be an awesome place for a Frosty’s.’”
Much like their decision to purchase the original location, the decision on the Freeport location was not a long process.
“We happened to randomly call to check on the information on the property in late May and they had an offer put in, but there was a short window (for us to make an offer),” Omdal said. “We threw something at them, and the next day, they accepted.”
The original plan was to have the shop open by the beginning of July to take advantage of the crowds coming to town for the L.L. Bean 100th birthday celebration, but renovation of the building, which had no water or sewer connected to it, took longer than expected.
“We’ve had to do a sufficient amount of work to the inside to get it where we needed to be,” Omdal said.
There will be no baking at the Freeport Frosty’s, Omdal said. All of the doughnuts will be made in Brunswick and sent to Freeport several times a day. That will have a positive effect on Brunswick’s customers, as well. In the past, the shop has been known to run out as early as 9 a.m., sending disappointed customers home with no doughnuts. Now, Omdal said, with the increased production for the Freeport location, there should also be doughnuts available all day in Brunswick.
In Freeport, the doughnuts will be finished, which will allow Frosty’s to provide an opportunity that is almost unheard of in doughnut shops, especially the big national chains. Omdal said he will be setting up stations where people can pick out unfrosted doughnuts and then have staff customize the confection with their choice of frostings and sprinkles.
“People can come through and choose what they want on them,” Omdal said.
Omdal he has high hopes for the new shop’s success.
“I think Freeport’s a great place for it,” he said.
Nels Omdal, who owns Brunswick’s Frosty’s Donuts along with his wife Shelby St. Andre, plans to open a Frosty’s on Main Street in Freeport next month.(Staff photo by Mike Higgins)
Comments are no longer available on this story