4 min read

In the days before Cape Elizabeth had 911 emergency service, Cape resident Henry Berry once called Cape’s emergency hotline because his house was on fire.

Berry recognized the voice of the man that answered the call immediately. “Greg, my house is on fire,” he said.

“We’re on the way,” said Greg Tinsman, a longtime Cape dispatcher who grew up in the town.

Dispatchers say that kind of personal service would be lost if Cape Elizabeth were to consolidate its dispatching with neighboring communities. That assessment came this week as Cape, Scarborough and South Portland received a final report on consolidating their dispatching services.

Dispatchers will meet with police chiefs from the three communities in a meeting at Scarborough Town Hall at 1 p.m. Feb. 16. The meeting is closed to the public, according to Scarborough Town Manager Ron Owens.

Causing concern

Advertisement

The potential consolidation causes concern for residents like Berry because immediately after Tinsman told him help was on the way, the line cut out. The electrical fire in Berry’s basement had reached the phone lines, leaving him without phone service.

The loss of service didn’t matter, however. Tinsman knew where Berry lived.

The Cape Elizabeth Police Department employs four full-time dispatchers, each with 10 plus years of service to the department. It is this longevity that brings stability and intimacy to the service, say Cape residents and officials.

Berry, a former town councilor, said consolidation is a “terrible” idea. “It ought not to be farmed out to some conglomerate,” Berry said of the dispatch services.

Berry has utilized the fire and rescue services in the past when his basement unexpectedly flooded. The Cape fire department responds regularly to calls for residential water problems.

Capt. Brent Sinclair said this usually translates into some kind of flooding, generally in the basement.

Advertisement

Berry fears this kind of service will no longer exist if dispatch consolidates. “The South Portland dispatcher is going to say, ‘sorry we’ve got a problem at the mall right now,'” said Berry.

Consolidation driven by mandate

Cape Elizabeth, Scarborough and South Portland are considering consolidating now, in part, because of a state mandate to consolidate the number of 911 call centers in the state from 48 to between 16 and 24. The communities, however, could decide to consolidate the center that receives all 911 calls and keep dispatchers in each community. The report explores the costs associated with that option, as well as building a new call center – something it deems financially insensible.

For Cape, the up side to consolidation would be new technology. Cape would have to upgrade their computer programs as well as put laptops in cruisers. The consolidation report by RCC consultants said consolidation for Cape “offers the best and perhaps only opportunity to obtain up-to-date systems.”

However, this upgrade comes at a still unknown cost to the town. If the three communities fully consolidated dispatch and 911 services, the cost would be around $400,000 for new computer programs and radios, according to the report.

Cape Town Manager Michael McGovern said Cape doesn’t need new systems right now. The service provided by the dispatchers is good, he said.

Advertisement

“It’s personalized; they know the streets, they know the callers,” he said.

A small percentage of Cape calls received are 911 emergencies. The report estimates approximately four calls per day are 911, compared to 73 administrative calls. Cape Police Chief Neil Williams said consolidating 911 calls wouldn’t be a problem. If 911 were relocated, dispatch could remain in Cape, relatively unchanged.

Scarborough and South Portland are contending for relocation rights. South Portland contested the initial draft report released last November, which recommended Scarborough as the consolidation center. At that time, South Portland City Manager Jeff Jordan cited inaccuracies about software, radio systems, and phone lines.

The final report recommended a consolidated dispatch and 911 call center be located in South Portland or Scarborough, but still favored Scarborough because their computer and radio systems are best suited for expansion.

The ‘leading edge’

South Portland is in the process of purchasing new computer systems, said Dispatch Supervisor Philip Viola.

Advertisement

If South Portland replaces its system, the report said, “the case for consolidating in Scarborough,” might not be as “financially compelling.”

Viola said it’s essential for South Portland to maintain its dispatch because their community is at higher risk than Scarborough or Cape Elizabeth. Though South Portland and Scarborough receive approximately the same number of administrative calls per day, South Portland receives, on average, 27 911 calls per day as compared to Scarborough’s 18.5. Viola’s argument for local control echoes Tinsman and others.

“We know the back roads. We know the best way to enter into a place,” he said.

Viola acknowledges that no matter where a fully consolidated 911 and dispatch center is located, somebody will lose local control. However, said Viola, South Portland will lessen that blow by providing top-notch service with high-end equipment.

“We want to be on the leading edge of technology,” he said.

Town councils in Cape Elizabeth, Scarborough and South Portland will be charged with deciding if a consolidated 911 emergency call and dispatch center would most effectively serve the three communities.

Cape Elizabeth Dispatcher Greg Tinsman

Comments are no longer available on this story