3 min read

Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield came before the state’s superintendent of insurance Tuesday to make its case for a 20.5 percent rate increase for the health-care plan it offers to individuals not covered under group policies – a rate hike health-care advocates called excessive and unnecessary given Anthem’s profits.

The state’s Attorney General’s office and Consumers for Affordable Health Care testified against the rate increase, saying it was not justified based on the amount Anthem was asking for in profit and administrative costs.

The consumer group also organized a protest press conference down the hall from the hearing room, where they called on the Legislature to create a nonprofit health-insurance agency “to take the profit motive out” of health care coverage.

Anthem is looking for anywhere from a 3 to 56 percent rate hike on its individual or so-called non-group plan, depending on the deductible level and type of coverage, but says the average increase is 20.5 percent. It says the plan lost $3 million last year.

The company also will be coming in next month to request a rate hike for the state’s subsidized Dirigo Choice insurance, which Anthem manages. The policy is supposed to make health insurance more affordable for the uninsured.

Anthem initially requested a 23 percent hike for individuals and a 10 percent hike for small groups using Dirigo Choice, but will likely bring that down to 18 and 5.5 percent, respectively, if granted approval to charge co-pays for doctors visits and drugs. Anthem says the same forces pushing up costs in the commercial individual market are at work in the subsidized individual market for Dirigo Choice.

Advertisement

The commercial plan for individuals, known as Health Choice, currently covers 29,500 people in the state, who don’t get coverage through an employer. Anthem said nearly 19,000 people in that group purchase a $5,000 deductible plan. If the rate hike is approved, persons aged 40 to 45 in that plan could see their monthly premiums go from $236 to $280 for a single coverage and from $625 to $742 for families.

Anthem says it is losing money on the product and that’s why it is requesting a rate hike.

Consumers for Affordable Health Care point out, however, the company made a profit in Maine of $40 million across all its product lines in 2005, including small and large group policies offered through employers. The small-group plan, which many of Maine’s small businesses offer, is expected to go up in the 7 to 11 percent range next year, based on anecdotal information in the market.

Anthem spokesman Mark Ishkanian said rate hike requests are not linked to profit.

“All these increases are driven by the cost of paying medical claims. They have nothing to do with profit,” he said.

Ishkanian said a small percentage of people in individual plans account for 40 percent of the costs, and their expensive health-care needs are driving up the cost for everybody.

Advertisement

Asking the company to absorb the loss in the individual market by paying for it with its more profitable lines simply “transfers the problem from one group of customers to another,” he said.

Doug Clopp, a spokesman for Consumers for Affordable Health Care, said part of the problem is the high deductible plans themselves, which are only used in catastrophic situations and not for care.

“The only thing that’s worse than being uninsured is paying to be uninsured,” Clopp said. His group would like to see the Legislature repeal or modify the law that allows high deductible plans in Maine.

House Republicans, who also held a press conference Tuesday, are looking for reforms of a different nature. They are calling for creation of a high-risk pool and the repeal of guaranteed issue, which says that any person, regardless of health history, has to be insured by a commercial carrier doing business in Maine. The sickest of the sick, they say, should be in a state-subsidized high-risk pool.

Republicans also are calling for changes in the law to allow insurance companies to base their premiums on a person’s health and age, allowing young, healthy people to pay much less than older ones, for example.

“It’s clear with a rate filing of a 20.5 percent rate increase that our health insurance market is broken,” said Rep. Ken Lindell, R-Frankfort, who sits on the Insurance and Financial Services Committee. “Anthem, no matter how much they charge, can’t operate profitably in this market.”

A ruling on Anthem’s Health Choice rate hike is expected within a month.

Comments are no longer available on this story