4 min read

The AJ’s “Westbrook: Then and Now” photos are always intriguing. Sometimes they capture change for the better – a dilapidated building, revitalized and given a new lease on life. Other times, they grimly testify to someone’s vision of progress gone sadly awry.

Soon, Westbrook’s most panoramic city street and one of its last open spaces may fall victim to the grim side of “Then and Now.”

Stroudwater Place would drop 1.65 million square feet of commercial development – 1.5 million in retail, restaurants and entertainment – onto 60 acres by Westbrook’s new middle school, a working family farm and rural/residential homes.

On Sept. 22, developers will present to the City Council their requested changes to the comprehensive plan and a contract zone application. They propose a “mixed use development of retail, office, recreation and civic facilities.” However, the lack of specificity in their proposal is alarming.

The current comprehensive plan allows commercial office development on that site, with limited support retail. It requires preservation of agricultural lands. The developers’ proposed changes would allow massive retail development without consideration of the agricultural lands, and would enable development that may or may not be mixed use at a 100 percent greater density/scale than is currently allowed. Moreover, they seek to decrease open space requirements by one-third. This clearly conflicts with contract zoning ordinance provisions requiring “restrictions on the scale and density of development” and “preservation and creation of open space.”

Contract zoning is authorized where “for such reasons as the unusual nature or unique location of the development proposed, the City Council finds it necessary or appropriate to impose, by agreement with the property owner or otherwise, certain conditions or restrictions ….” A negotiated instrument, a contract zone shouldn’t amount to a “free pass” based solely upon the statement that, at least for now, no public subsidy is requested.

Advertisement

Questions concerning this proposal abound. If this development is even economically feasible, does Westbrook want a mega-mall? America and southern Maine are already over-stored. Malone Commercial Brokers earlier this year issued this ominous forecast: “At some point (Maine’s) retail market is going to reach a level where there will not be enough consumers to produce satisfactory sales for all of these retailers to survive. Maine’s population and income rates are not keeping up with the vast amount of retail being built around the state.”

Predictably, the developers claim Stroudwater Place will bring jobs and tax relief. Yet we know that as an economic development strategy, retail is a “zero-sum game.” Maine’s economic pie is finite. More options simply carve smaller pieces, often diverting sales from local businesses to out-of-state chain operations. And, when the market is saturated and the stores go dark, what happens to the jobs and taxes?

The inevitable traffic congestion and access are not addressed. They propose access from the arterial and not Stroudwater Street, but try to envision entering the Maine Mall, which is one-third smaller, from just one street. Even with arterial-only access, how will thousands of vehicles get to the arterial? The traffic issue is being entirely and deliberately avoided, with the assurance it will be discussed later, at site plan review. Only problem is, at that point bringing those frightening numbers of vehicles past our schools and through our neighborhoods will be a matter of right. Contract zoning authorizes councilors to require (not merely request) additional information on traffic during their review. Let’s hope they exercise that authority.

This proposal raises more questions than it answers: There is no requirement for high-end retail. The much-touted skating facility would be built only after 1.2 million square feet of commercial space is occupied. They have argued repeatedly to allow a Class A lounge. (Class A lounges in Maine can offer off-track betting.) And sadly, the handsome Snyder house does not appear on the drawings.

The developers are asking the Council to approve a zone change without providing any specifics on who or what will be included in this zone. The representations and drawings shown to date are all “examples” and a “conceptual illustration of how the property might be developed.” Their application even states, “the exact mix, number, size and location of buildings, improvements and uses will be driven by economic circumstances and the needs of particular tenants and there may consequently be changes from the … February 2008 program diagram. Such changes do not require an amendment or revision to this Contract Zone ….”

The Council is being asked to approve this zone change as a ‘carte blanche” because all the specifics would be presented in the “Master Plan”/Site Plan phase of the application, at some later date, which could not be rejected then because the comprehensive plan and contract zone language are so general and non-specific that they allow virtually anything.

Would you enter into a legal contract that entirely lacks specificity and accountability? As the saying goes, “Let the buyer beware.”

Deborah Rumery is a resident of Stroudwater Street in Westbrook.

Comments are no longer available on this story