3 min read

Town Council Chairman Jeffrey Messer is calling for the resignation of the Conservation Commission Chairman Paul Austin in the wake of a messy dispute between the commission and town officials over the Eastern Village housing development.

“For us to heal, and move forward, I think the best thing would be for Mr. Austin to step aside,” Messer said in a telephone conversation Sunday.

He said Austin’s actions – contacting the Conservation Law Foundation and state officials to challenge that the housing development was improperly permitted, accusing the town manager and town planner of dishonesty, and calling the council a “kangaroo court” – were “inappropriate.”

“To cap it all off, when he had that verbal altercation with the town manager (in the hall after a council meeting), that was just totally out of control,” Messer said.

“I think the council has to sit down at some point and discuss the issue because there was conduct throughout this process that was really inappropriate,” he said.

Austin is out of town and did not respond to an e-mail from The Current by deadline. He has indicated in past interviews that he has no intention of stepping down.

Advertisement

Because the Conservation Commission is an appointed body, the Town Council can vote to relieve Austin of his duties.

However, only one councilor, Richard Sullivan, has said he would support doing so.

The Conservation Commission, an advisory body with no enforcement or permitting powers, began making waves in February when six of the seven members and Austin’s wife filed a petition with the Board of Environmental Protection challenging that the Eastern Village project had been improperly permitted.

That rankled Messer and other councilors, who felt it was inappropriate for a council-appointed advisory commission to be challenging the town Planning Board, questioning and criticizing the ethics of town staff, and exposing the town to possible litigation expense.

Messer attempted to get councilors to discuss the situation, and Austin’s removal, in a non-public session, but failed to get the 5-2 majority vote necessary to do so.

In an April 8 “Open Letter to the Town of Scarborough,” Conservation Commission member Jeannine Uzzi said commission members took the steps they did because of serious flaws in the development’s stormwater management plans that were going unaddressed by the Planning Board.

Advertisement

“The Conservation Commission made every attempt to address its concerns through normal town channels from April 4, 2005, until Feb. 19, 2008, the date of the Planning Board meeting at which Eastern Village came up for final approval,” Uzzi wrote. “When these channels proved unfruitful and Conservation Commission questions were not answered, particularly in the week before the Feb. 19 meeting, some members of the commission, along with one non-member, decided to petition the BEP as private citizens.”

Six of the seven petitioners were conservation commissioners; the seventh was Austin’s wife, Susan Wilder.

After the petition was filed, the developer made changes to the plans to address the storm water and easement concerns, and the BEP voted on April 3 to dismiss the petition.

But the bad blood the remains.

Without the commission’s perseverance, Uzzi wrote, the Eastern Village storm water management plan would have done less than the minimum required by the Department of Environmental Protection, with potentially serious impacts on the Scarborough Marsh. Nonetheless, she wrote, “the Conservation Commission has been publicly criticized and even threatened with dissolution by top Scarborough officials because of its role in the review of Eastern Village.”

Messer, for one, isn’t impressed.

“The permit (DEP) issued was on an extremely high standard,” he said. “I think that the permit more than protected the citizens of Scarborough.”

Uzzi did not respond to an e-mail seeking comment by the Current’s press deadline.

Comments are no longer available on this story