4 min read

In the aftermath of the Scarborough Conservation Commission’s row with town employees and Planning Board members last spring, Town Councilors plan to essentially ban the Conservation Commission from participating in development review.

The commission needs to “focus on areas that are more becoming of a Conservation Commission’s duties,” said Councilor Michael Wood, such as cataloging vernal pools and building nature trails, instead of publicly challenging Planning Board decisions and alleging less-than-scrupulous dealings by town employees.

Wood is asking the council to amend the conservation commission’s “charge” to remove the commission’s involvement in planning and development review. The The town Web page currently states that the Conservation Commission “undertakes a variety of tasks including review and comment on all development plans before the Planning Board…”

Wood and other councilors say they now want the Conservation Commission to focus more on building trails, inventorying vernal pools, combating invasive species, and other conservation-type activities.

The commission’s conflict with town staff and the planning board caused the council to review the Commission itself and the role it plays in town government, Wood said.

As a result, councilors will be directing the commission to concentrate on missions and duties that won’t bring it into direct conflict with other town boards, such as cataloguing and protecting marshlands, swamps and other wetlands.

Advertisement

“When you do a bit of study it’s obvious that development review, what they are doing now and have done for an number of years, is not a part of their duties,” Wood said.

Conservation Commission Chairman Paul Austin raised hackles in early 2008 when he accused the Planning Board of overlooking serious design flaws in its approval of a large housing development. Austin and other conservation commissioners also filed a complaint with state regulators that was later dismissed. The incidents infuriated Town Council members, who accused Austin and his supporters of far overstepping their duties as conservation commissioners and exposing the town to legal liability.

Although the furor died down in the ensuing months, Wood – a former Planning Board member – and Councilor Sylvia Most say they have been quietly researching the duties of Conservation Commissions in Maine and come to the conclusion that Scarborough’s had no business participating in the Planning Board’s review of Eastern Village in the first place.

Most and Wood recommended the Town Council specifically spell out the Conservation Commission’s duties and redirect its attention to projects such as studying vernal pools.

“This is not to be misconstrued as punishment,” Most said. “It certainly was precipitated by the events of this spring … This is where it ended up and I fully support it.”

She said the Conservation Commission may have served a valuable role as an advisory body to the Planning Board in the past, but today the town has strong ordinances protecting natural resources and the Conservation Commission’s role has become obsolete.

Advertisement

Not only has the commission been clashing with the Planning Board and town staff of late, she said, but the work “fully consumes them or nearly fully consumes them when other duties aren’t being done.”

By formally re-assigning the Conservation Commission to outside activities and essentially banning it from Planning Board chambers, she said, the town will benefit from valuable conservation activities while “ensuring that what happened this spring, for all intents and purposes, does not happen again.”

Most and Wood indicated that they had discussed the proposed “redirection” of the Conservation Commission’s energies with Austin; however, no members of the commission attended the July 16 council meeting where the changes were discussed.

In response to an e-mail from the Current seeking comment, Austin wrote that “we were not contacted about the discussion nor have we been informed of any conclusions resulting from the discussion, therefore, we can’t comment at this time.”

Commission member Jeannine Uzzi said she watched the meeting on public access television, but “the CC has not seen the document the (Town Council) was discussing, and we were not consulted in its creation. … I, personally, am hoping that the (Town Council) will share the document with us at some point; if that happens, I’ll be glad to comment then,” she wrote.

Bob Shafto, executive director of the Maine Association of Conservation Commissions, said that many of Maine’s 67 Conservation Commissions do participate in planning board reviews, but the role they play in each town is up to town leaders.

Advertisement

“Quite a number of Conservation Commissions do review property subdivisions and … property development in their communities,” he said. “In other towns, they might be dealing with invasive species and land use. They play whatever role the community wants them involved in.”

According to the Scarborough town Web page, “The Conservation Commission’s primary responsibility is to increase awareness of the value of our natural resources, work to identify and reduce potential damage to these natural areas and to proactively work with Town Staff, other committees, and local organizations to encourage sustainable stewardship of these resources.”

Councilor Sylvia Most said that the Commission may hve played an important role when it reviewed planned development years ago, but today the town’s environmentally sensitive ordinances render the Conservation Commission’s participation obsolete.

“Today, I’d say that our ordinances are much stronger,” she said.

Councilors did not take any action on the recommendations. They will continue their discussion at their next council meeting, Aug. 20.

The Conservation Commission’s seven members, Austin, Uzzi, John Cole, Bob Jordan, Patrick Kelly, Kelley Pendleton and

Silla von Faulk Trueworthy, are appointed by the Council and serve at the council’s discretion.

Comments are no longer available on this story