4 min read

Two pitchers have been on my mind recently, but for different reasons.

One, Brandon Webb of the Arizona Diamondbacks, won the Cy Young Award in the National League. The other, Christy Mathewson, was one of the greatest pitchers of all time and among the five players – along with Babe Ruth, Honus Wagner, Walter Johnson and Ty Cobb – who in 1936 comprised the first group of players selected for induction into the National Baseball Hall of Fame.

What a contrast between the two. Webb won 16 games and lost eight with a 3.10 ERA, statistics that in past eras (or even a couple of decades ago) would have qualified him for a middle-of-the-rotation spot on a good pitching staff. Now, he is hailed as the greatest National League pitcher of 2006. With the lowest win total ever for a starting pitcher who won the Cy Young Award in a full season, Webb might be seen as the emblem of mediocrity that has afflicted pitching generally in the majors. That contagion of mediocrity seems also to have spread to the World Series. The St. Louis Cardinals, at 83-78, claimed the worst regular season won-lost record ever for a World Series champion.

Let us return to Mathewson, a figure from a long-distant past, who exemplified excellence in all that he did. A college man in a time when few ballplayers had gone beyond high school (indeed, many never finished high school), he so distinguished himself with the New York Giants as a paragon of virtue that he earned the sobriquet, “the Christian gentleman.” With World War I raging, Mathewson resigned as manager of the Cincinnati Reds and went abroad, to return home dying from mustard gas that had demolished his lungs.

As a player, Mathewson 13 times won 20 or more games in a season. Three times he won over 30 games. His dominant pitching earned him another nickname, “Big Six,” after New York’s most famous fire engine. New Yorkers noted that Mathewson was able to power through the enemy batting order as ably as their fire engine could roar its way down New York’s streets. In the 1905 World Series, he pitched three shutouts in a space of six days.

Yes, Mathewson embodied excellence both on and off the field, which makes him a worthy subject to discuss even in classrooms. And that, during these closing days of the fall semester, is precisely what I have been doing at my college in a course that I call Modern Literature, Baseball, and Society. Mathewson figures prominently in a fine novel, “The Celebrant,” by Eric Rolfe Greenberg.

Advertisement

I am far from alone in bringing baseball into a college classroom, that environment traditionally, at least ideally, dedicated to academic excellence. McFarland and Co. of Jefferson, N. C., recently published a book of mine entitled “Baseball in the Classroom: Essays on Teaching the National Pastime.” When I first thought of the book and sold the idea to McFarland, I was not sure how the project would fare. My plan was to solicit essays in which college faculty explain how they use baseball to teach their respective subject areas. Would there be many faculty who, in fact, actually use baseball this way?

Once my call for submissions went into some newsletters and online discussion groups, I got my answer: decidedly yes! The inquiries and submissions flowed in. I ended up selecting 20 essays, including one of my own on my use of baseball in the aforementioned course and in my writing classes.

The range of courses in this volume is broad, including law, business, history, film, labor relations, philosophy, public speaking, race studies and Native American history. John Vernon, of the National Archives and Records Administration, writes about how instructors can locate archival materials for instructional use. Another Maine professor, Michael Brady of the University of Southern Maine, describes his experiential course on baseball and American culture taught aboard a motor coach traveling among a variety of baseball stadiums.

So we return to Mathewson and Webb. The former can be likened to the A student, the latter to a C-plus one. Perhaps it is time for a little remediation for major league pitchers, possibly for big league baseball overall. Those pitchers need to spend a few more hours mastering their homework, sharpening their skills, hitting their baseball books. It is time to join baseball once again to excellence before all those college professors find another way to teach their students how to master modern financial principles, understand the complexities of labor-management issues or apply Kant’s practical imperative.

Football anyone? Well, not yet. Let’s keep Christy Mathewson in mind, write out a few more cogent assignments for the Brandon Webbs of the world, and keep baseball where it rightly belongs, on the diamond and in the classroom.

Edward J. Rielly is a Westbrook resident, English professor at St. Joseph’s College and widely published author with three books on baseball and American culture.

Comments are no longer available on this story