3 min read

The citizens of Scarborough will be asked in the upcoming election to vote on $55 million in school infrastructure projects. It’s difficult for the public to get a clear understanding of the size and scope of these projects. Let me take a moment to add some clarity to the issue.

The town debt in fiscal year 2002 was $35.1 million. The town debt in fiscal year 2005 was $67.8 million. This significant increase in debt (nearly double) was primarily because of the $26.8 million addition to the high school, which was the most expensive locally funded project in Maine history. We must carefully consider further adding to this debt.

The question before the voters is: Do the benefits of the project justify the costs, or are the costs very excessive? There is no doubt the middle school, although relatively new, has a capacity issue, and the intermediate school has outlived its useful life. However, Scarborough just recently funded the most costly local project in state history. Do we now ask our citizens to shatter this record by more than double the amount? We need to find a better answer. We need to be more realistic. Consider the following:

The current intermediate school (including modulars) is 105,000 square feet. The proposal on the ballot is to tear down the existing facility and construct a new building with 185,000 square feet. The proposal is to nearly double the size of the current facility, even though capacity is not an issue.

A report presented to the State Board of Education by the Office of School Facilities indicates the national median is 125 square feet per student at these grade levels. The state requirement is 125 square feet per student. The figures provided by the architect are for 197 square feet per student, 58 percent higher than the national median and state requirement. Schools with comparable enrollment that were recently built in Kennebunk, Lisbon and Old Town schools have between 125-135 square feet per student. Are we being excessive?

The report further indicates the national median for middle schools of similar size is 145 square feet per student. The state requirement is 135 square feet per student. The architect’s figures are for 184 square feet per student. Middle schools with comparable enrollment recently built in Waterboro, Biddeford, Kennebunk, Gorham, Oakland, Topsham and Cumberland have between 135-145 square feet per sudent. Are we being excessive again?

Advertisement

What is it that causes our needs to be so much greater than the rest of the country and the state? It would cost approximately $25 million less if these projects were built to the national median or state requirements. Coming on the heels of the high school project, we must ensure these projects are built with a conscious blend of fiscal responsibility and realistic need. We must have a better balance.

It’s very unfortunate the cost impact figures presented in the glossy brochures were so convoluted. The numbers presented clearly underestimate the tax impact. The format used makes it nearly impossible for the average citizen to understand the tax impact. Furthermore, the brochures list the average residential assessment as $290,000. According to the tax assessor, the average residential assessment is $372,000. You were given wrong information.

A simple calculation would be to borrow $55 million at 5 percent for 30 years. This yields an annual payment of $3.6 million. Adding this figure to the current budget results in a $1.07 increase in the tax rate, which is a tax increase of $400 for the average assessment in the first year. This figure will decline slightly year to year as the town continues to grow. The total cost for the average assessment would be $9,600 over the term of the bond.

I would suggest a no vote on these projects, because the costs far exceed the relistic needs of our students and taxpayers. We need to continue to support quality education for our children. I would suggest setting a budget for about half of what is currently proposed to address this issue. We need to develop a more realistic request and then go to the citizens via referendum and ask for their support.

Jeffrey Messer is a Scarborough town councilor.

Comments are no longer available on this story