4 min read

The Westbrook City Council voted to send the question of whether to elect or appoint a city clerk to residents, after an at-times heated debate Monday.

City councilors voted unanimously to let voters decide the matter, despite vocal opposition from Mayor Bruce Chuluda and former Mayor Bill O’Gara.

The debate Monday was prompted by a proposal from City Councilor Ed Symbol, who believes the city would be better served by an appointed clerk. Symbol has said he thinks as long as the city clerk position remains elected, the person holding the position will not be accountable to city administrators – only to residents every two years. If the position were a full-time city employee, he said, the person would be accountable every day.

O’Gara questioned why the city council is considering changing the position when he had not heard any complaints about either of the two clerks who have held the position for more than five decades. In the last 50 years, Westbrook has elected only two city clerks. Bill Clarke, for whom William Clarke Drive is named, held the position from 1956 to 1993. City Clerk Barbara Hawkes replaced him in 1994.

“If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it,” said O’Gara.

O’Gara disagreed with Symbol’s assertion that an elected clerk is difficult to hold accountable, saying the position is accountable to Westbrook residents every day. Referring comments made by Symbol for a story that appeared in the March 22 edition of the American Journal, O’Gara said his argument was “uneducated.”

Advertisement

In later remarks during the meeting, Symbol said he found O’Gara’s comments to be disrespectful.

City Councilor Mike Foley, who would also like to see the city clerk become a city employee, said changing the position could help bring about improvements to the services offered at city hall.

As long as the position remains an elected one, Symbol said, city administrators can’t force the clerk’s office to make any changes to the services it offers. Clerks are elected every two years, and they can run the office as they see fit, he said. For example, Symbol said, he would like see a single counter at city hall with employees behind the counter trained in every service the city offers. Now, different clerks offer separate services at multiple counters.

Foley said that because times have changed, particularly with new technology, the position should change along with it.

“I think it’s time to change,” he said.

The position of city clerk in most cities across the country has become more specialized as both election laws and technology have increased in complexity, making the position one where training is required. Many are of the opinion that someone can’t walk in off the street and do the position anymore.

Advertisement

Linda Adams, a former deputy city clerk for Westbrook under Clarke, said during her tenure from 1989 to 1993 she found herself performing the bulk of the city clerk’s job at times because Clarke was unable to keep up with changing technology and election laws.

Adams said the position now is similarsto other administrative positions at city hall, which are professional positions, and the city clerk should follow suit. In that way, the city would be assured of getting a qualified candidate into the position.

“As we all know, elections can turn into a popularity contest,” she said.

When asked what training is involved these days, Deputy City Clerk Ruthie Noble, a certified municipal clerk, said she has taken steady courses on changing technologies and election laws for the last seven years to keep up.

Laffin Drive resident Jim Garland told the council he thought it was time to make the position a professional one. He said the city needs a qualified person and shouldn’t be afraid of progress.

“We need to move forward and get with the times,” said Garland.

Advertisement

According to the Maine Municipal Association, Maine has 195 elected city or town clerks and 248 that are appointed. Mike Starn, spokesman for the association, said in an interview for previous story that the trend is moving toward appointed clerks in larger communities. As communities move away from a mayoral form of government toward a city administrator form of government, the other elected positions, such as the clerk, tend to follow suit.

Siding with O’Gara was Mayor Bruce Chuluda, who said he had not received any complaints about the position. Chuluda said he didn’t think it was right to hold a referendum on the item without more public debate.

Symbol countered that the item has received attention in numerous newspaper articles, most notably ones announcing Monday’s public hearing. Despite that, only a handful of residents showed up to speak.

In the end, the council voted unanimously to put the item on the May 22 referendum, which will also include a vote on the new junior high school slated to be built on Stroudwater Street. The May 22 date is three weeks before a previously discussed date of June 12. It was moved to accommodate the school department, giving its architect, Harriman and Associates, more time to prepare final construction plans and to bid out the junior high project to contractors.

Comments are no longer available on this story