A budget battle over trash, initially waged in connection with Mayor Bruce Chuluda’s first proposed budget in 2004, is looming once again.
In his proposed budget released to the Westbrook City Council on Monday night, Chuluda included a trash disposal and curbside recycling program based on a pay-per-bag collection system, a program some councilors have already indicated they plan on rejecting.
The proposed city budget for 2007-2008 contains a spending increase of approximately $2.6 million, a hike of 5.2 percent. The total amount of the budget to be raised through property tax is just under $30.7 million, which, using current city property values, would result in a 3.5 percent increase in the tax rate to $24.70 per $1,000 of valuation.
However, City Administrator Jerre Bryant said the tax rate would decrease dramatically when the citywide property revaluation is completed this summer. Since revaluation is expected to increase property values throughout the city, the tax rate will correspondingly decrease. But that does not necessarily translate to lower tax bills. Bryant said the final tax bill would be based on the new property value.
Bryant said the city is hoping to send out initial notices of new values to property owners in mid-June and have the entire revaluation process completed by the time the tax assessor sets the city’s tax rate in July.
In 2004, when Chuluda’s pay-per-bag proposal was shot down by the council, he attempted to revive the program by using a rare line-item veto of the full trash budget, a move that was swiftly overridden by the council.
In March, a committee appointed by the administration to look into possible changes to the city’s trash collection program recommended to the council’s Committee of the Whole that the city adopt a pay-per-bag trash program combined with a curbside recycling program. Councilors chose to go against that recommendation, instead asking the administration to investigate the possibility of implementing a curbside recycling program without moving to a pay-per-bag collection system.
The budget includes a total spending increase of just over $278,000 to implement both pay-per-bag and curbside recycling. However, Bryant said, if pay-per-bag were to be implemented, the net effect on the tax rate would be zero. Bryant explained that even though spending would increase, the city would also realize an additional $281,000 from the sale of bags, adding that the program provides for 26 free bags for each residence annually.
Bryant said the administration feels the only way to bring a curbside recycling program to the city is to implement pay-per-bag at the same time, which is why it went with the recycling committee’s recommendation over the council’s wishes.
“What pay-per-bag does is that it funds curbside recycling through a revenue source other than the property tax,” said Bryant. “The challenge of the budget I think will be to eliminate pay-per-bag but fund curbside recycling.”
It looks like it will be a challenge the city will likely have to face. Several councilors have spoken out against the proposal, and have said they believe it will be eliminated from the final budget.
Councilor Ed Symbol, who chairs the council’s budget and finance committee, said he is adamantly opposed to pay-per-bag.
“You can call it whatever you want,” he said. “Pay-per-bag is a tax.” Symbol added that he plans to push for curbside recycling to be implemented and paid for through the budget.
Bryant said if the city went with a curbside recycling program without pay-per-bag, the program would cost more than $300,000. Bryant explained that the increased cost is from an additional collection truck that would be required to collect the recycling. With a pay-per-bag system, Bryant said, the volume of trash collected would be reduced, which would allow for trash and recycling to be picked up by one truck.
“I don’t think there’s support for pay-per-bag on this council,” continued Symbol. His opinion on pay-per-bag recycling was shared by Councilor Drew Gattine, who also said he was against the proposal.
Council President Brendan Rielly said he was worried that asking taxpayers to pay for trash bags was too much to ask.
“I do have concerns about this budget,” he said. “My primary concern is that a 3 percent tax increase coupled with an additional $280,000 in fees on top of that is too much.”
However, Councilor John O’Hara has been a longtime proponent of pay-per-bag and he indicated that he would continue to push to see the system implemented in Westbrook.
“As a supporter of pay-per-bag, I find the funding of curbside recycling through a pay-per-bag system has always been the goal of this community,” said O’Hara. “Pay-per-bag works.”
In addition to including pay-per-bag, Bryant said, in coming up with this budget, the administration attempted to make sure the city provided the best services with the least possible increase in taxes.
“We’re trying to have a reasonable investment in our infrastructure, and we’re able to do it with essentially a 3.5 percent increase in the tax rate,” said Bryant. “If we’re going to maintain service levels, respond to citizen need and maintain infrastructure, we’ve got to provide funding for it, and that’s what this budget does.”
The Westbrook City Council’s budget and finance committee will be holding review sessions on May 10 at 6 p.m., May 12 at 8 a.m., May 17 at 6 p.m. and May 24 at 6 p.m.
All meetings will be held in room 114 at Westbrook High School and are open to the public. The meetings will also be televised on cable Channel 3.
Comments are no longer available on this story