5 min read

CAPE ELIZABETH – After Cape Elizabeth voters rejected a $6-8 million plan to reconstruct the 95-year-old Thomas Memorial Library in 2012, a more detailed, smaller-scale proposal to renovate and expand the facility, pegged at $4.3 million, is headed for the November ballot.

The 2012 library plan was defeated due to the cost and scope of the proposal, according to library director Jay Scherma. While 2,696 residents voted for the plan, 3,566, voted against it.

The $4 million renovation project is the culmination of several years of planning and community meetings, and Scherma said it would ultimately address the library’s longtime structural deficiencies and meet the needs of Cape Elizabeth.

“I think it has a solid chance of gaining broad support from voters,” he said. “I have faith that the proposed project can serve the library needs of Cape’s citizens.”

The new renovation plan asks voters to approve a $4 million bond for the renovations, as well as a $200,000 contingency fund for unanticipated expenses, and another $150,000 to provide temporary library facilities at the former Spurwink School during construction.

According to Scherma, the 2012 proposal was rejected in part because the town was “in a period of economical insecurity,” as it was still recovering from the 2008 recession.

Advertisement

In addition, “There was quite understandably a great deal of confusion in the public’s mind about the project’s shape and scope,” he said. “I think because of all the iterations and revisions that were made public during the long design phase, no one was certain about what exactly they were voting on.”

Now, it seems that residents have a clearer understanding of what the project entails, he said.

“I think it’s a good idea to trim down the cost, and now I think that the project is doable,” said John Serrage, who has lived in Cape Elizabeth for 45 years.

Serrage said that while he is not a regular patron of the library, he does, on occasion, check out the audio books.

He said he praises the Town Council and the Library Building Committee for taking residents’ comments into consideration when they crafted the new proposal for the library renovation project.

“They were listening to the people,” Serrage said.

Advertisement

In December, the Town Council appointed a five-member Library Building Committee to develop a less-extensive proposal for the library renovations.

Molly MacAuslan, chairwoman of the Library Building Committee and a member of the Town Council, said the 2012 plan would have increased the size of the library from about 14,500 square feet to 22,000 square feet. The new plan calls for expanding the library to about 16,000 square feet, MacAuslan said.

Under the proposal, the Pond Cove School annex, the existing main library that fronts Scott Dyer Road would be renovated to become more energy efficient, and a two-story addition would be constructed. While the lower level would become the children’s area and offer space for meetings and programs – including an outdoor play space and reading garden – the upper level would house the adult and young adult collections, and technical services.

According to Scherma, “the project offers people a facility that has been designed with considerations for all (users),” including an adult section that balances study space and social space.

The plan will retain the popular artist gallery space and add a small media lab, which will be available to the public outside of normal library hours, said Scherma.

In addition, the existing 1985 connector building between the main building and children’s building will be removed, and a pedestrian connection between the library and the adjacent elementary school will be created in its place. The plan also includes adding an outdoor stage for performances and about 50 more parking spaces.

Advertisement

“The design not only corrects all the deficiencies of our current building, it has the flexibility to meet the town’s needs for the next generation and more,” Scherma said.

The Cape Elizabeth Historical Preservation Society, which is housed at the library, will be temporarily moved to the police station while renovations take place, and the town will find the society another permanent home, said Scherma.

Amy Stanley, who has lived in Cape Elizabeth for six years, said she supports the $4 million proposal and that a larger, updated library would promote learning for people of all ages and would strengthen education in general.

“I felt like the last proposal did not succeed because it was too expensive and the aesthetics did not match the feel and style of the town,” Stanley said. The current plan is a better fit, she said, and seems to be more reflective of the community’s needs.

“It’s a huge asset for Cape Elizabeth,” she said of the Thomas Memorial Library.

The project architect is Reed & Co. Architecture of Portland. Zachau Construction of Freeport would be the construction manager.

Advertisement

When asked whether the Town Council or Library Building Committee has heard any opposition to the library plan, MacAuslan said, “I have not heard a peep.” But she doesn’t rule out the fact “there will always be people who are concerned about how the tax dollars are spent.

“We’ve done the best job we can,” she added.

“If you look back over the last 100 years or so, about every 20 to 25 years the community has made a concerted effort to address the library needs,” said MacAuslan.

If approved by voters, the renovation and expansion of the library would begin early next year and is expected to take 10 months, she said.

“It’s overdue. We think it’s the right project, at the right price, at the right time,” said MacAuslan. “I don’t want to count my chickens before they hatch, but I’ve heard very good feedback.”

Paint peels on the outside of the Thomas Memorial Library building on Scott Dyer Road in Cape Elizabeth.  This 1985 connector building between the original Pond Cove School annex and the Spurwink School at the Thomas Memorial Library would be removed and replaced with a pedestrian connection if voters approve a $4.3 million bond for a library renovation and expansion on Nov. 4.  

Comments are no longer available on this story