Just when you thought it was safe to watch a professional hockey game without cringing, along comes Chris Simon of the New York Islanders.
By now, many of you have seen Simon’s vicious attack on New York Ranger player Ryan Hollweg from a couple weeks ago. Simon took exception to Hollweg’s checking him against the boards and he retaliated by deliberately hitting Hollweg in the face with his stick. Hockey fights are one thing, but brutal assaults are quite another.
Luckily for Hollweg, he only needed a few stitches and he was playing again in the following game. Anyone who saw the stick-swinging incident knows he could have been injured very badly and some NHL observers said he could have even been killed.
Simon received a 25-game suspension from the league office and he will not be allowed to play in the playoffs should the Islanders make it that far.
Coincidentally, this most recent on-ice attack came three years to the day after one of the most infamous episodes where the game of hockey turned into a criminal incident. In 2004, Vancouver’s Todd Bertuzzi’s disgraceful mugging (from behind) of Colorado’s Steve Moore led to a universal outcry for these senseless acts to stop. Bertuzzi pushed Moore’s head to the ice and landed on top of him breaking three vertebrae in Moore’s neck.
And all of this violent behavior is justified by some players and some fans who plead “that’s how the game is played and that’s how it’s been played in the NHL for a very long time.” Many others would disagree with that statement.
I’m not going to be a hypocrite and tell you I’ve always turned away at the start of a fight in a professional hockey game. I grew up with Bobby Orr and the big, bad Bruins of the early 1970s so I expected a fight or two each time the Bruins took the ice. But as I’ve gotten older I realize that the fighting wasn’t why I loved to watch the game. It was the speed of the skaters, the stick skills and amazing passing ability exhibited by the league’s crafty forwards and the incredible saves of a hot goaltender that kept me glued to the tube.
Yes, there are occasional scuffles between enforcers of opposing teams, but recent years have seemingly seen more “attacks” by players seeking some type of revenge for an earlier hit on them or a fellow teammate. In some instances, these cheap shots take the form of purposely trying to injure one of the opponent’s better players as some type of necessary retribution.
I have a couple ideas.
If the NHL isn’t going to ban fighting completely, they should set aside a few minutes at the end of the first and second periods for these “necessary” fights to take place. Stop the game and send the teams’ enforcers to center ice for a true “face-off.” Last man standing gets a point for his team.
One other thing the NHL might try is “designated fighters.” Captains and assistant captains wear the letters C or A on their jerseys, and fighters would wear the letter F. Only players wearing that F jersey would be allowed to get into fights, but they would not be allowed to pound anyone not wearing an F from the opposing team.
There are a number of fans that attend professional hockey games hoping to see as many fights as possible. Little do they know (and little do they care) that these fisticuffs are nothing but a sideshow to the main event. The real beauty of the game is in the athleticism of the players not the punishment in their punches.
What really puts this into perspective for me is that I recently spent a great deal of time watching many of our local high school hockey teams in tournament play. Terrific efforts made for tremendous games and not a single hockey glove was dropped to the ice. I always marvel at how well these kids play the game and I always wish every level of hockey were played in the same way.
Arguably the most memorable hockey games the average American sports fan remembers were played during the 1980 Winter Olympics in Lake Placid, N.Y. The “Miracle on Ice” team from the United States won the gold medal that year without any on-ice fighting and certainly without any on-ice assaults.
Is ice hockey a rough and tough game filled with hard hits and physical play? Absolutely. Is it a game that requires an occasional bare-knuckle brawl in order to be appreciated? Absolutely not.
The eye for an eye mentality and the need for revenge too often turn this wonderful sport into an ugly form of mayhem that should no longer be tolerated as “part of the game.”
Comments are no longer available on this story