SOUTH PORTLAND – A plan to address a school budget shortfall by holding a furlough day for South Portland teachers and staff is now off the table after one employees’ union rejected the idea.
On Feb. 10, the South Portland Administrators Association, the South Portland Teachers Association, the South Portland Educational Support Professionals Association and the South Portland Service Employees Association voted on the proposed furlough day agreement, according to School Superintendent Suzanne Godin.
All four bargaining groups needed to agree to the furlough day because the schools would have had to shut down completely to save $140,000 in the school budget.
However, the service employees’ group, which represents bus drivers, maintenance and custodial workers and food service employees, rejected the proposal, saying in an issued statement that “having public servants fund public education” is not the answer to the budget problems.
Godin released a statement last week saying that, “since a unanimous ratification was needed to move forward, the furlough day will not occur.”
The furlough day was proposed for April 26, which now will remain on the schedule as a staff in-service day. Teachers and other staff would have stayed home without pay on the furlough day, but students would not have lost any instructional time. That’s because students don’t attend classes on in-service days. Those days are for staff training and development, and the furlough day would have meant one less opportunity for staff development.
Godin said South Portland now will use $140,000 it has in federal stimulus funds to help fill the $1.2 million gap in this year’s budget. However, Godin said, that money was intended to reduce an even bigger gap of $2.4 million in the upcoming 2010-2011 school budget. More staff cuts now will have to be made in that budget to make up the $140,000, she said.
Godin said on Friday said she was disappointed that the furlough day won’t take place. However, she added, “I also appreciate the willingness of the associations to put the idea of a furlough day before their members.”
The Board of Education in December endorsed the furlough day proposal as one of the ways to balance the $1.2 million loss in state education aid in the current 2009-10 school budget of $39.4 million. The curtailment was part of $38 million in cuts in education aid to school districts statewide. The cuts were the result of a huge state budget shortfall in the economic recession.
The furlough day was just one of the measures planned in order to balance the budget.
Other measures include a spending freeze that Godin instituted last fall, which is expected to generate $473,000 in savings to offset the cut.
The School Department’s entire contingency fund of $150,000 also is expected to go to balance this year’s budget. And $13,200 in savings is anticipated as the result of eliminating non-essential overtime pay and because school clerks agreed not to work on snow days.
The plan also was to use $454,000 of some federal stimulus money the school district received last year.
That would have left $260,000 in stimulus funds remaining to carry over into the new 2010-2011 school budget.
That budget won’t take effect until July 1, but already has an estimated $2.4 million shortfall. The deficit is due to an additional reduction in state aid to South Portland that totals nearly $1.7 million and other increasing costs facing the schools, such as higher fuel and unemployment insurance expenses, school officials say.
The City Council, which sets the bottom line of the school budget, has ruled out raising taxes to address the shortfall.
So Godin has said that the deficit will mean the loss of 30 to 50 positions, larger class sizes, the possibility of closing some schools and perhaps requiring students to pay for extra-curricular activities. Now, with $140,000 less in stimulus money to reduce the budget shortfall, Godin said on Friday, two to four additional staff positions will have to be cut.
She is expected to present details of her budget proposal to the school board on Feb. 24 at 7 p.m. at Memorial Middle School.
Godin said the furlough day was recommended by a budget curtailment task force that she convened this fall in anticipation of the cut in state aid. Leaders of the four associations were part of the task force, Godin has said.
Godin declined on Friday to identify the group that rejected the vote. She said she agreed with the associations that she “would not single any one (union) out,” and instead let the groups speak for themselves.
The service employees union on Sunday sent out a press release identifying itself as the group that voted down the measure.
The statement said the 55-member association is “made up of caring and committed professionals” who “provide an exceptional level of service to the students, staff and general public.”
The statement said that members “respectfully disagreed with the proposed (furlough day) measure.”
The reason, according to the statement, is that “while we truly do sympathize with the current economic conditions here and around the country, we do not feel that the answer lies within having public servants fund public education.”
The vote was 18-12 against the furlough day, according to Stephen Doherty, vice president of the association. He said service employees have some of the lowest salaries among school staff.
In the statement, the service employees association offered to assist in “bringing forth new and creative ideas” to help with the budget process.
The president of the administrators’ association said that group voted in favor of the furlough day. Kathy Germani, principal of Mahoney Middle School, declined to give the specific vote taken by the 14-member association, but said it was almost unanimous.
“We had already taken a pay freeze, and we were willing to go with a furlough day to save some money in the budget,” Germani said. Administrators got no wage increase this year, she said.
Tom Major, a South Portland High School history teacher who is president of the South Portland Teachers Association, could not be reached for comment.
However, Major said on Feb. 10 in a blog he writes for the association that the group ratified the furlough day agreement. He did not give the tally. “I deliberately did not reveal vote totals because I understand the vote to be our collective voice,” he wrote.
Major had written in an earlier entry that members had “good reasons to support and to oppose this proposal.”
The head of the educational support professionals association could not be reached for comment by the Current’s deadline.
Comments are no longer available on this story