Is sending tar sands through Maine worth the price of clean water? That’s a question we need to ask ourselves when considering the potential use of the Portland-Montreal pipeline to carry tar sands oil across Maine.
This pipeline literally criss-crosses the Androscoggin and Crooked rivers, and the entire Sebago Lake watershed. The combination of increased chances of a tar sands spill, and the increased toxicity and greater environmental damage that tar sands oil poses when spilled, make it clear that sending tar sands across Maine in a 60-year-old pipeline is an all-risk, no-reward proposition for Maine people.
Just ask the good people of Mayflower, Arkansas.
A few weeks ago, an ExxonMobil pipeline carrying tar sands oil from Canada burst beneath a suburban neighborhood, flooding yards and streets and leading to the evacuation of 22 homes in Mayflower, a small town about 20 miles from Little Rock. The exact size of the spill hasn’t yet been determined, though local police said the line gushed oil for 45 minutes before being stopped, and at least 84,000 gallons of tar sands oil poured through yards and down streets damaging neighborhoods and sending residents fleeing.
The similarities to our Maine situation are striking.
Both pipelines are about 60 years old and both are owned by Exxon or its affiliates. Both were built to carry conventional crude oil. The Arkansas pipeline was reversed in 2006 to carry tar sands to the Gulf of Mexico for export. The Maine pipeline could be reversed to carry tar sands across Maine to Casco Bay for export.
Twenty-two homes in the Arkansas subdivision remained evacuated on Monday, with local police escorting residents to temporarily return to retrieve personal items.
Some of these homes have oil on their foundations, some oil that made it to the street went into storm drains that lead to Lake Conway, a local fishing hole. Firemen, city employees, county road crews, and police rushed in to build dikes of dirt and rock to block culverts along that path and stopped crude from fouling the lake, just in the nick of time.
It is painful but hard not to imagine such a future scenario in Raymond, Casco or Bethel or in Sebago Lake, the Androscoggin River or Casco Bay.
These disasters show that pipelines fail, oil spills, and, when that happens, people and our environment pay the price. For the last two years, we have been telling the story of the huge tar sands spill into the Kalamazoo River in Michigan from another aging crude oil pipeline reversed to carry tar sands. The oil industry, including here in Maine, has tried to say that spill was unique, and they have every incentive to prevent tar sands oil spills. Of course they want to prevent tar sands spills. But last week re-affirms the hard truth: they can’t.
The Portland Pipeline Company owned by Exxon subsidiary Imperial Oil, has tried to wave aside public concerns because of the company’s previous track record of very few spills and because they do regular maintenance on the pipeline. But that justification just doesn’t hold water. An ExxonMobil spokesman in Arkansas said the company’s recent inspections of that pipeline showed no red flags for that section. The federal government has shown that leak detection systems work 17 percent of the time.
This brings us to another critical question. Does the pipeline company really think that its previous safety record means the company should get a pass on permitting and on a full environmental review of a tar sands retrofit? If not, why is the company fighting so hard not to have to apply for a new Presidential Permit that would require a new Environmental Impact review?
Although we and so many others from this region think this tar sands plan is a bad idea, what we’re asking for is a clear decision from the U.S. State Department that there will be a permitting process that will consider the environmental risks to Maine. We wish the pipeline company, which keeps claiming it can transport any oil safely, would stop opposing that.
So, why should Maine pay the price so giant oil companies can export more high-priced oil to rake in more profits?
And why should we trust a pipeline company whose statements about this project have been all over the map? Why should we waive environmental reviews when there is so much evidence showing tar sands pipelines have greater risks?
It is clear that we simply cannot afford to risk Maine’s economy, our drinking water supplies, our lakes and streams, our shellfish and fishing resources, and a future of catastrophic climate change for this chancy tar sands scheme.
Lisa Pohlmann is the executive director of the Natural Resources Council of Maine.
Comments are no longer available on this story