3 min read

WESTBROOK – The Westbrook City Council narrowly approved the first reading of the Pike Industries consent agreement by a 4-3 vote Monday after representatives from Smiling Hill Farms and Artel, abutters to the property, said the order still didn’t make the agreement right in their eyes, or in the eyes of the court.

“History will show one thing, that the city had numerous chances to revisit this,” said David Bertoni, president of Artel. “If I can predict anything, this agreement is going to be a litigation freefall.”

Nearly two hours into the discussion, Council Vice President Michael Foley ended it by asking for a vote on the amendments. Councilors Paul Emery and John O’Hara, and Victor Chau, who represents residents in the quarry district, voted against the amendments.

It comes up for a final City Council vote on Feb. 4.

The agreement is the culmination of years of negotiations centered on how Pike can operate its Spring Street quarry, including specifications such as when blasting can occur and the number of trips trucks can make in and out of the quarry each day.

New amendments, like specifying where the blast vibrations will be measured, were ordered by the Maine Business and Consumer Court to fix discrepancies between the consent agreement and zoning amendments that went into effect in October. Both the zoning amendments and the original consent agreement previously had been approved by City Council.

Advertisement

“Clearly not everyone is happy, but a lot more people can live with it,” said Pike’s attorney, Sigmund Schutz, with the firm Preti Flaherty in Portland.

For neighbors to the quarry, the agreement represents unequal treatment between large and small business.

“We weren’t large enough to be included in this agreement. Equal treatment is important. It’s been treated as cumbersome and challenging at some points,” said Warren Knight, owner of Smiling Hill Farms. “We live, we work, we play, we die. We’ve been there for over 300 years and hope to be there for 300 more. Just like others that live out there, we’ve made investments.”

Knight said despite the farm’s history and his attending some 45 meetings on the issue, his concerns still have not been met. Knight wants a 100-foot, natural vegetative buffer around his property. He said there is now 20 feet or less of buffer.

“There are significant buffer requirements in the consent order,” said City Solicitor Natalie Burns. “The buffer can’t be expanded in some areas. There’s not any more area to install more buffer.”

O’Hara, Chau and Emery urged the parties to make one last effort to sort out any disagreements before the next meeting on Feb. 4.

Advertisement

“If you’re looking at 200 years of sustainability, what’s the hurry at the last moment, at the eleventh hour? All I’m trying to say is if you had anything to give, now is the time to give it one more shot,” O’Hara saud.

City officials and Idexx and Pike representatives were scheduled to meet with a judge on Wednesday, after the American Journal deadline, to discuss a timeline on the amendments.

A representative from Pike, which hasn’t used the quarry since July, said at the meeting that the company wanted to start working at the Spring Street operations again in May.

Discussion on the quarry agreement was tabled at the Jan. 7 council meeting to allow more residents time to review changes. Only Knight, Bertoni and Tim Bachelder, chairman of the Spring Street Quarry Neighborhood Working Group, were at the meeting Monday.

“I think this is the time to make a decision. We’ve said from the onset we were never going to get to the end of this process and have everyone embrace it and say ‘Hallelujah,’” said Westbrook City Mayor Colleen Hilton.

In other action Monday, councilors unanimously approved awarding a $31, 730 bid to Custom Float Services Inc. of Portland for the purchase and installation of three floating ramps and docks to be set up on the Presumpscot River for the public for recreational use.

Final approval was also given to Police, Public Safety Dispatchers and Public Services union employee contracts that change health benefits and pension plans. The contracts run from July 1, 2012, to June 30, 2015. Human resources policies and procedures changes to employee health insurance and pensions were also approved.

Comments are no longer available on this story