7 min read

The Standish woman accused of setting multiple fires around southern Maine in recent years is still behind bars after a York County Superior Court judge upheld bail of $100,000 during a hearing Tuesday morning.

The arrest of 65-year-old Carol Field, of Standish Glen off Route 35, has baffled area residents, neighbors and those affected by the fires Field, a former nurse at Maine Medical Center and Subway sandwich maker, is accused of starting.

While investigators have said that Field may be involved with 18 fires at various locations in York and Cumberland counties during the past two years, Field was arrested Friday, Sept. 30, at her home and charged with three class A counts of arson for a fire last month in Limerick that damaged a vacant home, and one last fall at Plummers Hardware store on Main Street in Waterboro. Field was also charged with setting the fire that nearly destroyed the Raymond Hill Baptist Church this summer. According to the State Fire Marshal’s Office, each count is punishable by up to 20-30 years in prison.

In addition to the three charges, investigators say Field is also a suspect in 15 other fires at vacant buildings and wooded areas in the two counties, according to Steve McCausland, spokesman for the Maine Department of Public Safety.

A team of agents from the State Fire Marshal’s Office, the Maine Forest Service, the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives and the York and Cumberland sheriff’s offices combined their efforts this summer to investigate the fires, McCausland said.

Field became a suspect in early September, McCausland said, after a witness saw a car leaving one of the fire scenes and gave investigators a partial license plate number, which led them to her Standish address.

Advertisement

The Lakes Region Weekly interviewed the eyewitness, who declined to be identified publicly.

According to the witness, on Friday, Sept. 16, a car with its brake lights on was parked on the roadway in front of an unoccupied home on Central Avenue in Limerick. Thinking it strange that the car, a blue Chevrolet Cavalier, remained parked for about five minutes in front of an unoccupied dwelling, the witness went out to investigate. Approaching the car, the witness noticed a fire in progress at the home.

The witness then saw the suspicious car spin around in the road and drive off. Not able to see the license plate as the vehicle drove by and believing the driver was linked to the fire in progress, the witness followed the suspect’s vehicle. After catching up to the car, the witness recorded the license plate and called 911. Dispatchers relayed the information to investigators, who could not locate the license plate saying the numbers didn’t match.

The next morning, the witness went into Limerick and noticed a blue Cavalier with a similar license plate. The witness recorded the proper plate number – the original recording was off by two digits – and called police with a cell phone. Police told the witness to stay with the vehicle and that a Maine State Police trooper would arrive shortly. The witness stayed on the phone with the dispatcher while following the Chevy Cavalier. Within minutes, a trooper pulled up in back of the witness’ car communicating with the witness to pull over and to follow the trooper’s vehicle.

According to the witness, the driver was not a 65-year-old woman, although an older woman in her 60s arrived on scene shortly afterward in order to retrieve the vehicle.

The case, which has made news around the country due to the involvement of a suspect who doesn’t fit the usual arsonist profile, is in its infancy, with Field likely to be arraigned soon. Her lawyer, J.P Degrinney, a criminal defense attorney based in Portland, said Tuesday that Field is intending to enter a “not-guilty plea across the board” for the three counts she is charged with, as well as the 15 other arsons for which investigators may soon bring additional charges.

Advertisement

“She strikes me as a very nice older lady, the type that would never hurt a fly,” DeGrinney said, “But she has a lot going on. She’s had a very rough life. And she certainly has some health and mental health issues.”

DeGrinney said it’s “too early to tell” whether he would request a mental health evaluation. Representing clients accused of serious crimes for the last 14 years, he said many of them have had mental issues that don’t have legal implications, “but, if we find it appropriate, we will seek an evaluation,” he added.

Field has lived in Standish for “years and years,” DeGrinney added. Neighbors have said she had family troubles and, DeGrinney said, “It’s fair to say she’s been in a lot of distress emotionally.”

While many are shocked at the arrest of a 65-year-old woman who had no criminal history, DeGrinney said he believes she will get a fair trial.

“I’m a big believer in the jury system and I think her case can and will go to a fair trial,” DeGrinney said. “And I intend to see to it she’s given the presumption of innocence.”

Standish life

Advertisement

Neighbors of Field on the short Standish Glen road, which runs off Route 35 south of Standish Corner, report stunned disbelief when it comes to their longtime neighbor’s alleged involvement with multiple arsons.

David Patterson, who operates a community radio station out of his home across from the Field residence, was shocked when told Field had been arrested on multiple arson charges.

“She was a registered nurse, general duty, per diem, as I recall. And she actually took care of my mom a couple times here at the house. But she was always hospitable, so I can’t really see her doing this, and I can’t imagine she had anything to gain from setting fires,” Patterson said.

Another neighbor, who did not want to be identified, paints a different picture of Field. The neighbor said, “She was not very friendly, and basically a grumpy old lady.”

The neighbor recalled that Field would walk her dog along the street and that once she was caught peeping in a neighbor’s window.

“She seemed odd, she had kids and they were always fighting with her. The cops were there sometimes,” the neighbor said.

Advertisement

After her nursing career ended, Field got a job about four years ago at the Standish Subway, located within a short distance from her Standish Glen home.

The shift leader there, Amethyst Brunick, recalled Field as “hot and cold when it came to being friendly. She’s got to like you. With some of the regulars, she would joke around.”

According to Brunick, Field worked at Subway for about three years up until a year ago. Fellow employees, she added, were stunned with the news.

“When I see Carol, I don’t see fire, but you don’t really ever know a person I guess,” Brunick said.

Raymond response

Field is accused of setting mainly home and brush fires. While authorities report no one was injured or died as a result of the fires, a historic barn was destroyed in Limerick and an historic Raymond church escaped serious damage July 26 thanks only to quick response by Raymond and five other area fire departments on July 26.

Advertisement

One of the oldest structures in Raymond, the Raymond Hill Baptist Church on Raymond Hill Road was built in the early 1800s and is one of the three oldest church buildings in Maine.

The church still meets for four weeks in the summer and is maintained by the Baker family, which lives nearby. Speaking for neighbors and church members who have wondered when an arrest in the case would be made, Deb Baker said she is “definitely relieved” that a suspect is in custody.

“Knowing that, people in the neighborhood are feeling safer now,” Baker said.

Like Field’s neighbors, Baker said people in the church community are dumbfounded that an older woman is the suspect.

“Who would have guessed it would be a 65-year-old woman. That’s extremely unusual,” she said.

Joe Thomas, assistant state fire marshal, said in his 42-year fire fighting and investigating career, he has only seen one older woman accused of setting fires.

Advertisement

“Yes, it’s unusual to see an older woman. You do see females involved sometimes, but the lowest percentage of fire-starters we encounter are older women,” Thomas said.

The church, Baker added, is undergoing significant renovations after the July fire destroyed most of the back wall of the building. She said some items not covered by insurance, such as chairs, carpets and a curtain, will either be rehabbed or replaced using money from a fund set up at the Key Bank in Raymond. Donations for the “Raymond Hill Baptist Church Special Fund,” which total $700 as of this week, are still needed, she added.

“People are coming together. A man named Bob Bickford donated a beautiful organ to the church, so there are good things happening,” Baker reported.

Baker is most appreciative of the fire marshal’s investigators, who called Saturday to tell her of the arrest, and is still wondering why the church was targeted.

“People have asked what the woman’s connection was and honestly, no one’s aware of any connection, and I’m not sure what reason she would have,” Baker said.

-Reporter Kate Irish Collins contributed to this story.

Carol Field

Comments are no longer available on this story