The city of Westbrook is one of the few communities in Maine where an elected mayor has administrative authority over city hall, where most local candidates are still chosen by political parties at caucuses and just about every elected official runs for re-election every two years.
Being different, however, doesn’t make it the best form of government. These practices are part of a long tradition in Westbrook, but they are also antiquated.
City Councilor Ed Symbol has proposed adding some language to the city charter that would remove political affiliations from the ballot, in an attempt to encourage more people to run for office.
This move is now being opposed by most of the candidates who are in office. That’s not surprising. Most of them were elected with the backing of one of the two major political parties.
Despite the opposition, Symbol is right. It makes sense to include political affiliations on the ballot at the state and national level, where most of the candidates are experienced or professional politicians. But in a small community like Westbrook, it puts too much influence in the hands of a few and stifles candidates and ideas that aren’t aligned with one of the parties.
There’s nothing inherently wrong with political parties. They provide a common platform for candidates with similar ideas and a cue to voters as to what the ideas of a particular candidate might be.
However, when people can’t get elected to an office without joining either the Republican or Democratic party, then something’s wrong. While Westbrook city councilors are sometimes elected as independents, it’s a commonly held belief that candidates can’t get elected as mayor without the backing of a political party. Elected as an independent city councilor, Bruce Chuluda joined the Republican Party shortly before he ran for mayor.
Those who run as part of a political party get the support of members of that party in organizing their campaigns, and they get all the straight-ticket votes. That’s particularly difficult to overcome for local candidates, who typically have little, if any, political experience.
Candidates who fall out of favor with the leaders of a political party can also get frozen out of the process. Paul LeConte, for example, feels that in the late 1990s, after six years on the city council, the Democratic Party held a caucus on a weekday when he was on vacation to keep him from running, after years of holding caucuses on weekends. (For the record, LeConte said he didn’t have a position on Symbol’s proposal.)
Changing this part of Westbrook’s political system, however, faces an uphill battle. Those who are in office now will oppose it because they are depending on the support and influence of the parties to help them get re-elected.
That’s why anyone who sees the benefit of taking political affiliations off the ballot needs to speak out at the public hearing Monday night, at room 114 of Westbrook High School, and go to the polls June 12 and vote for change.
Brendan Moran, editor
Comments are no longer available on this story