3 min read

The RSU 14 Board of Directors consists of six members from Windham and three members from Raymond. This fact is creating a perceived imbalance for the people of Raymond. The present school idling issue on the table isn’t making things any easier.

The board’s current proposal is to close Jordan-Small Middle School in order to save an estimated $230,000 annually, the plan involves moving students across the street to Raymond Elementary, and it doesn’t sit well with the majority of folks from Raymond. A popular additional option is to redistrict part of Windham’s student population to Raymond schools to relieve overcrowding and fill in some of the excess capacity in JSMS and Raymond Elementary, an idea not garnering much support from Windham parents.

Any option may be temporary as Windham hopes to build a new Middle School designed for both Raymond and Windham students. The board submitted an application to the Maine Department of Education for a new Middle School this past spring and we should know where the RSU is on the priority list in the summer of 2011.

Here’s where that perceived imbalance comes into play: Do board members elected by Windham voters choose to redistrict and alienate those who voted for them? Do they vote to close Jordan-Small furthering the rift between the two communities? Or, do they do nothing at all in the hopes that they can scrape together savings elsewhere until a new middle school can be built in a central location?

Additionally, serious design flaws abound in the state’s legislation of school consolidation. Some Raymond folks suggested simply seceding from the RSU, a tact which is completely omitted from Maine law as it is written. Why am I not surprised?

It seems that we are creating a lot of headaches for what may be a temporary situation. The board’s proposal to close JSMS may be incredibly expensive, far more so than any “savings” could ever possibly recuperate. Any updates made to Raymond Elementary could also become obsolete once the new middle school opens. Redistricting students to Raymond, while not expensive from a financial standpoint could be politically difficult. Either option creates obstacles for the students being relocated, only to be transitioned again if a new school is built. Any transition will affect student achievement, which is something that we definitely cannot afford.

If the state decides that RSU 14 isn’t a priority, we may need to consider the more extreme options. Before we go jumping off a bridge we really should understand how deep the water is below. Therefore, any proposal needs to be completely understood and backed up with complete data before being presented to the general public. That’s not to say that we shouldn’t be contacting teachers’ associations and PTO/PTA organizations for their opinions and alternate solutions. Wouldn’t it be much easier to get things done if we had the support of the teachers, principals, and other staff?

Lots of growing pains lay ahead for our young RSU 14. Patience, understanding, and a little give and take will be necessary for our students to thrive. After all, isn’t that what it’s all about?

Christopher Dunn lives in Windham.

Comments are no longer available on this story