A CLOSER LOOK
The primary election will be held on Tuesday at the Cape Elizabeth High School gym. Polls are open 7 a.m. and close at 8 p.m.
In a 4-3 vote that seemed to satisfy no one, the Cape Elizabeth Town Council narrowly approved a $3.8 million 2008-2009 school budget May 27, a 4.6 percent increase over the current year.
The budget approved will face a town-wide validation vote on June 10. An advisory question on the ballot will ask all voters whether they think the increase is too high or too low, to guide the Town Council in revising the budget for another vote should the 4.6 percent budget fail.
The budget was in excess of the 4.3 percent target originally set by the Town Council, but $263,083 lower than the 6 percent increase originally sought by the School Board.
Councilors Paul McKenney, Mary Ann Lynch, David Backer and Cynthia Dill voted in favor of the 4.6 percent increase. Cynthia Dill, James Rowe and Anne Swift-Kayatta opposed it, Rowe and Swift-Kayatta because they felt it was too high, and Lennon because she felt it was too low.
Of those who voted in favor of the budget, Backer and Lynch made clear that they would have preferred a different number, but supported the 4.6 percent increase in order to advance the question to voters.
Backer said he had sought a 4.92 percent increase, while Lynch said she would have preferred a 4.3 percent increase.
“It’s not a perfect budget by any means, but democracy is not a perfect process,” Lynch said.
Backer noted that there was a “unanimous show of support” from the public for a higher school budget at a hearing on May 12, but added that the few dozen people people who spoke were not necessarily representative of the several thousand taxpayers in Cape Elizabeth.
“The only way to know for certain is to give taxpayers the opportunity to accept or reject it,” he said. “The privacy of the voting booth will be a great equalizer.”
At two polar extremes of the council were fiscal conservatives Swift-Kayatta and Rowe, who poo-pooed the idea that the schools need a 6 percent increase, and Lennon, who argued passionately that school costs are far outpacing inflation and that Cape Elizabeth could bankrupt its academic excellence, its future and even its property values by underfunding the schools.
Swift-Kayatta said that school expenses have increased 33 percent in six years and enrollment has been flat during the same time period, and declining since 2006. Meanwhile, she said, personal incomes are growing at a much slower rate if at all, and nearly one in five Cape Elizabeth families receives income-based property tax relief.
“The issue here is not whether we cut (the school budget),” she said. “The issue here is how much more do we spend.”
Rowe sounded a similar theme.
“I can’t control fuel, food or other costs, but as a town councilor, I can at least try to control (local taxes),” he said. By approving a school budget increase that outpaces other communities’, he said, “we might as well hang a sign on the town hall that says people of moderate or even average means are not welcome to live here.”
“In a nutshell, … school expenses grow faster than inflation,” Lennon countered, listing state and federal mandates, fuel costs, staff and health insurance costs, and the growing responsibility of schools for their students’ health and social and physical well-being as some of the cost drivers.
Cape Elizabeth, she said, has “more money to spend on our schools than any other town in the Greater Portland area,” and yet continually spends less than most of them, and that the Town Council was acting counter to the public will in cutting the school budget further. She said the 4.3 percent budget would result in “firing teachers, cutting administrators, reducing projects.”
“Is below average really what we are seeking?” she said. “Is this the way we run our our businesses, our law practices and our households?”
She challenged that the Town Council was “insert(ing) itself in the middle” of the democratic process by cutting the School Board’s budget before presenting it to voters.
In supporting the 4.3 percent increase, McKenney and Dill took a more moderate approach. McKenney noted that the schools have been affected by council-imposed spending caps through several previous years, and that the overall increase over those prior years and in 2008-09 would be a modest 2.85 percent. He also urged residents who are concerned about town expenses to recycle, which, he said, would save several hundred thousand dollars per year.
Dill noted that she has two children in Cape Elizabeth schools and urged students who lobbied the Town Council May 12 to support the 6 percent budget to continue to advocate to the School Board, which will decide which programs and positions ultimately get cut.
Both fiscal conservatives and spending advocates said they welcome the June 10 vote.
“No matter how you feel on this issue, go vote,” Lennon said. “Go vote, and let us know.”
Comments are no longer available on this story