SOUTH PORTLAND – The South Portland City Council has declared the building at 35 Mildred St. to be a public nuisance and has given the property owner, former state Rep. Christopher Muse, 15 days to fix the problem.
During that time, Muse is also not allowed to live at the multi-family building, which has been declared unfit for human habitation by the city’s code enforcement office.
In addition, before anyone can move back into the building, staff from the code office must be allowed to conduct a thorough interior inspection of the property.
The latest issue at the building is a collapse in the private sewer line leading from the public sewer into the property, according to Patricia Doucette, the city’s director of code enforcement.
On Monday the council held a public hearing to decide whether the property constitutes a public nuisance. The hearing was held after the city received a petition signed by about 20 neighbors.
Muse was on hand for the hearing, but refused to acknowledge that there was any issue at his building, saying he didn’t recognize the condition of his property as it was described by the fed-up neighbors.
“Either I’m right or they’re right, I don’t know what else to say,” Muse said.
He also told the council that he suffers from “memory problems,” which he described as either early onset of Alzheimer’s or some other neurological disorder.
A former Democratic state representative from South Portland who served for three straight terms until 2002, Muse also told the council that renting the units in the building is currently his only source of income. According to city records, he purchased the building in 1992, and its assessed value is $280,800.
While Muse did not confirm it, several councilors and Sally Daggett, the city attorney, all said it’s their understanding that he is facing foreclosure on the building, which was originally built in 1910 and which at least one neighbor said was once the jewel of the neighborhood.
When it became clear that the council was going to designate his building as a nuisance, Muse sent a handwritten note to Mayor Gerard Jalbert indicating the property has been sold.
However, councilors said whether there is an actual contract for sale, it’s their duty to relieve the distress of the neighbors by doing what they can to remedy the situation.
During their testimony before the council, the neighbors all said the sewer problem at 35 Mildred is just the latest in a long line of ongoing problems caused by Muse and his tenants.
In opening the public hearing, Kevin Alvarez, who lives at 40 Mildred St., told the council, “I really don’t want to be here doing this, but I feel that we’ve been left no choice.”
He said during the last five years Muse has violated every one of the nuisance conditions numerous times and said that as early as 2011 a clean-up crew in full protective gear arrived at 35 Mildred to deal with a sewer rupture.
Alvarez also said the neighbors are aware that Muse has been cited many times for not providing heat or hot water for his tenants, as well as failing to install smoke detectors and fix the unsafe back deck, as well as the front porch.
He also said that Muse does not tend to his yard, which is overgrown and threatening to take over the garden of the adjacent home. And, Alvarez said, that several times Muse has pumped raw sewage directly into the street, as well as into his own yard.
In all, Alvarez said, Muse is in “blatant noncompliance” with the city’s nuisance property ordinance and said, “I am flabbergasted and speechless. Every time I think I’ve seen the worst, something worse happens.”
Guy Frenette, who lives at 36 Mildred, also complained about trash not being picked up, roaming dogs, loud parties at all hours of the night and “undesirable tenants,” which are all having a negative impact on the quality of life for the neighborhood.
“I could go on for hours and hours about the problems at 35 Mildred St.,” he added.
Frenette’s wife, Carol, said she and her husband bought their home more than 30 years ago and at that time Mildred Street was “a wonderful neighborhood.” But now she’s afraid to let her grandson play out front due to the activities going on next door.
Carol Frenette also read an email from someone who intended to rent an apartment from Muse, but when she found out about the conditions at the building she tried to get her deposit back and could not.
This prospective tenant called Muse a “slum lord” and said his building should be torn down. And Doucette, the code officer, said the South Portland Housing Authority has stopped referring clients to Muse because of his track record and the state of the property at 35 Mildred.
Another neighbor, Dawn Pacillo, who lives at 39 Mildred, said in the last decade there’s been a “dramatic downswing” in the condition of Muse’s property. She said the deterioration of the building is “far worse than a broken sewer main.”
When it came time for the council to decide what action it wished to take, Mayor Gerard Jalbert said, “This is obviously a very, very difficult situation.”
While he supports the rights of private property owners, Jalbert also said those owners have a responsibility to their neighbors and the rest of the community to ensure it’s not a nuisance.
Jalbert said Muse is either “unable or unwilling” to fix the situation and that’s why the city must step in. Daggett said if Muse does not fix the sewer problem within 15 days, the city could go to court to enforce its will.
Councilor Tom Blake said that while he also supports the rights of private property owners, “we have a responsibility to provide a safe neighborhood.”
When asked, Doucette told the council she’s had numerous problems with the building during the past four years and showed a file that was about 2 inches thick.
She said that in accordance with city policy she’s tried hard to work with Muse to bring his building up to code, but it’s been impossible.
Councilor Maxine Beecher said that in addition to the collapsed sewer, it’s her understanding that electrical power to Muse’s building is likely to be turned off soon due to nonpayment of his utility bill.
“If we don’t do something, the situation is only going to get worse. I’ve heard from neighbors how difficult it is to live next to this house,” she said.
Councilor Melissa Linscott agreed and said she’s heard directly from neighbors several times during the past five months.
“There is obviously a long, long history here and it’s a difficult situation, but given the current conditions of the property we should move forward” in declaring it a nuisance, she said.
Councilor Patti Smith said to ensure a safe community, the collapsed sewer “is a hazard that must be dealt with immediately.”
And Councilor Linda Cohen said the situation with Muse’s building is “one of the hardest issues that the City Council has to deal with.”
She added, “I can’t imagine what the neighbors have gone through. This is a bad situation all the way around. We can’t wait. The neighbors need immediate relief.”
Former state Rep. Chris Muse owns this multi-family building, located at 35 Mildred St. in South Portland, which has been deemed a health hazard.
Comments are no longer available on this story