4 min read

The South Portland City Council had more questions than answers Monday night, as members discussed whether to outsource legal work when Mary Kahl, the city attorney, leaves her post March 7.

At issue are the rising legal challenges and costs the city faces with such diverse issues as employment, land use and police conduct. The City Council is trying to decide whether to replace Kahl with another full-time general counsel or hire an outside private firm to do the legal work.

At a City Council workshop Monday, some council members said they at least want to explore contracting with a large legal firm, which would have various legal experts on staff. They said that using legal specialists to handle cases may be more efficient than having a full-time staff attorney.

Others said that an in-house lawyer is indispensable for the daily needs of running the city. City Manager Jim Gailey said he supports having a staff attorney to assist him and the 12 department directors who help run the city.

Councilor Maxine Beecher said she worried about how the process might work if there were no longer a full-time attorney at City Hall to take calls from councilors.

“I would worry about calling these fellas or girls at an outside law firm,” Beecher said. “I would wonder, can I talk fast enough, since we would be paying for the (lawyer’s) time?”

Advertisement

Kahl provided for the City Council a memo she originally wrote for former City Manager Jeff Jordan that compares using in-house legal services and privatizing the work. She noted the city of Portland employs six full-time attorneys and a support staff, and still has the need to use outside counsel for

highly specialized cases.

“With outside counsel, the perception that ‘the meter is always

running’ and the logistical problems of finding legal counsel if an immediate problem arises can lead to less legal advice at an early stage,” Kahl wrote in her memo to Jordan. “Outside counsel is more likely than in-house counsel not to get

called in until after a problem has become entrenched.”

Gailey offered a spreadsheet to the City Council that projects the costs for using an in-house attorney versus paying an outside firm to handle the city’s legal work.

Advertisement

Kahl’s annual salary is $86,000. She also receives benefits, subscriptions, training and $18,000 in help from outside attorneys for when she is on vacation or has a conflict. The total package is $141,000.

By contrast, the city may have to pay outside counsel a total of $156,000 for just 20 hours of work weekly, if the attorney’s rate is calculated at $150.

The cost would increase to $292,500 for 37.5 hours of legal help weekly, which is the amount of time Kahl provides as full-time city attorney.

Gailey noted that $150 an hour may be a conservative estimate, since the going rate for many lawyers is $200 an hour.

Councilor Claude Morgan noted that the City Council at this point does not know how much a law firm would charge, if the city were to retain its services. He said it is possible that with a guarantee of a minimum number of hours, a firm would lower its hourly rate.

Also unanswered, he said, is which lawyers a firm might assign the city – junior attorneys or lawyers with more experience?

Advertisement

Councilor Tom Blake also had questions. He wondered what the Maine Municipal Association recommends, since it provides the city with insurance to cover its liability in several different areas.

He also wondered what the experience has been of other municipalities, including Gorham and Westbrook, which contract with outside legal help, instead of employing a full-time general counsel.

He questioned whether the city might hire a paralegal to handle day-to-day questions from city staff, if the City Council chose to contract with a private legal firm.

Councilor Kay Loring pointed out that the $141,000 for Kahl’s salary, benefits and other services does not represent the city’s total legal bills in 2007.

She noted the city also had an additional expense of $117,000 for outside legal help, which brought its total costs for legal services to $258,000.

Gailey noted that the $117,000 was above what the city budgets for outside legal services, in addition to Kahl’s work.

Advertisement

He said the city’s current budget for outside legal help is

$33,000. “We overspent last year,” he said.

Kahl’s office is budgeted for $18,000 and human resources gets $15,000.

Councilors noted that the city has faced an increasing number of lawsuits. Some councilors wondered aloud whether outside legal counsel might speed some of these cases to resolution.

Ongoing cases include Theodore Wainwright’s lawsuit against the city over property he sold to South Portland in 1999. Wainwright claims the city violated deed restrictions by allowing Maietta Construction to remove loam from the fields.

The city also has had ongoing court cases over its attempts to limit traffic on Edgewood Road, which used to end at the Cape Elizabeth line but was extended when the Blueberry Ridge subdivision was developed.

Two homeowners have been fighting the city over its decision to remove access rights to Edgewood Road for their Cape Elizabeth homes.

The City Council concluded that it needs more information before making such a critical decision. Gailey plans to talk with municipalities such as Westbrook that contract legal work and also seek bids and information from law firms.

Departing South Portland City Attorney Mary Kahl is considering going into animal law.

Comments are no longer available on this story