RAYMOND – A lousy economy, the prospect of two chain hotels coming to nearby North Windham and a lack of capital helped bring on the demise of the White Pines Inn at Sebago Lake, a quaint and well-cared-for motel in Raymond owned by the Libby family.
Mark and Susan Libby, whose two children attend Windham High School, said they gave it their best, but debt, lack of a year-round clientele and a need to constantly heat the 11-room motel, which also had a large living quarters for the family, necessitated the closure just before Christmas. An auction on the property abutting Route 302 takes place Friday, May 3.
Mark Libby, 44, said it was a losing battle beginning about two years ago when bills became overwhelming and too few customers were showing up in the lobby.
“We bought in 2007 and things rapidly, and then gradually and for the long-term, went on the decline. And we just weren’t in a position to wait it out,” Libby said last week.
Libby bought the motel for $630,000 and said he put more than $150,000 worth of improvements into it. He expanded the living quarters to two floors for his family. He also tried to improve the heating efficiency in the units in hopes of reducing the estimated $70 a day the facility required in heating oil. But with few winter lodgers, but a need to keep rooms warm in case visitors arrived, the heating bill alone became overwhelming.
“We made a lot of changes to improve the building and we did the best we could do with the resources we had,” Libby said. “But just heating an empty hotel in the winter was just not feasible for us anymore.”
When Libby read late last year that the Windham Planning Board had granted approval for a new three-story hotel on Route 302 in North Windham, he knew he had to make a decision.
“That was pretty much the deciding factor,” Libby said of the MainStay Inn & Suites planned for North Windham. “That and another tough winter and we decided to call it good.”
Mark’s mother Betty Libby, who also lives in Raymond and held some of the debt in the motel, seconded her son’s decision to close.
“The new hotel is just ridiculous, we’d never survive,” she said. “We had over 4,000 guests from all over the world. I think we had two complaints. People would say it’s clean, it’s cute, it so quaint. But it still doesn’t matter. When push comes to shove, the fuel costs alone buried us.”
The Libbys were working with People’s United Bank and received a second loan from the Small Business Administration and Coastal Enterprises. They were unable to continuing paying on the loans. According to Mark Libby, he still retains title to the property but he doesn’t expect to get any money as a result of the May 3 auction.
“If it sells after all the banks are paid, the lawyers are paid, the auctioneer is paid, and the assessors are paid, everyone who needs to be paid, I don’t anticipate it’s going to sell for upwards of $700,000,” he said. “But in the end we’re still the title holder, but I’m not holding my breath on that one.”
The Libbys said they gave the endeavor everything they had.
“It’s one of those things. We put our heart, our soul, or blood, sweat, tears, the whole shebang, right into it, and it was time to make a decision,” Mark Libby said. “It was a tough decision but in the end it was the only one we could have made.”
He said his wife’s paycheck went to pay the mortgage, and because of the nature of the lodging business and the inability to hire a manager, someone in the family was always at the motel.
“Every penny we had went into it,” he said. “There was no extra. I think in our six years there we went to one Red Sox game. We went to Washington, D.C., for three days. And that was it.”
Betty Libby said that constant effort was hard on the family, and she’s proud of her son and daughter-in-law.
“My son, I don’t think he left that property for any family occasion or function for the entire time that we owned it except for one vacation they went to Washington and I went down and stayed [at the motel]. So that’s quite a price for the entire family to pay,” she said. “So they really tried their best; we all did. And we feel badly, but we feel like we at least tried.”
The Libbys said they could have survived if they didn’t have to try to make a go of it in the winter. Summer weekends were excellent, Mark Libby said.
“The location was not ideal,” he said of Raymond’s location halfway between Portland and the ski areas. “But even in the summer, the biggest thing was our lack of ability to accommodate those six really busy weekends a year. Like I say, if I had an inflatable hotel with 400 rooms, I could rent them for about six weekends and then deflate it, roll it back underneath the shed, call it good, and we’d be fine.”
Mark Libby said he believes the perfect buyer at the upcoming auction would be a retired couple with money in the bank who summer in Florida and want to run the White Pines in the summer.
“Or convert it to a B&B and shops,” he said. “There is all kinds of potential. You could put a restaurant in there; the living room is enormous. Maybe an Italian restaurant the area could support and would support.”
Sam Gifford, co-founder of the Raymond Revitalization Committee, a group of businessmen, town officials and residents that seeks ways to better Raymond’s economy, said prospects for a new use of the White Pines sound promising.
“The fact that they’re going to sell it off is pretty exciting because it does have possibilities. The location is terrific and that’s the kind of thing we’re looking for,” he said. “It’s built as a lodging establishment but if it had that capability and some sort of a restaurant capability, not necessarily in competition with A La Mexicana, but for people coming here for vacation, that would be a great spot for people to stay, almost like a B&B. So that sort of thing makes sense.”
There are several small year-round motels in the nearby area – Alyssa’s Motel in South Casco, Windham Way Motel in North Windham and Sebago Lake Lodge in North Windham – who the Libbys competed with for customers, especially in the dead of winter. Now Libby wishes them luck as chain hotels eye North Windham.
“Everyone who remains in the lodging business in the area, I wish them all the best, especially the smaller ones,” he said. “I hope the big ones do equally as successful, as they anticipate they will. And we’ll take our 11 rooms out of the inventory, so there’ll be at least 11 more calls that they’ll get.”
White Pines Inn, Raymond
Comments are no longer available on this story