3 min read

The Broad Cove Neighborhood Association has filed a countersuit in the dispute over what is know in Cape Elizabeth as “Secret Beach.”

The countersuit argues residents of the entire Broad Cove neighborhood have a right to access the 125-foot beach and an adjoining walkway. The association has asked the court to “order” Woods “to stop interfering with residents exercising these rights.”

The entire 250-home neighborhood earned prescriptive rights to the beach, claims the association, because they’ve been using the beach and maintaining the easement since Alan Balfour began developing the neighborhood in the early 1970s. Under a Maine Law prescriptive use grants ownership rights to any group or individual proving uninterrupted undisputed use for 20 years or more.

Woods said he expected the countersuit. Woods maintains that only certain lots, noted on his land deed as lots J-27 to J-45, have rights to the easement. “The mere assertion of a prescriptive right does not create a prescriptive right,” Woods said in November.

The suit filed Dec. 12 is a response to the suit filed by Paul Woods and Helen Muther on Nov. 14. Woods and Muther are suing the Broad Cove Neighborhood Association, and two members of the Assocation, Beth Hess and Leslie Connolly, for trespassing and slander of title. Woods, who lives at 20 Running Tide Road, claims that his deed grants access to residents of 17 lots near his home only.

Woods rented the $1.4 million home for two years before purchasing it a year and a half ago. The Association contends that Woods understood and never challenged the conditions of the easement until nearly a year after purchasing the land. The neighborhood group disagrees that the subdivision map grants access to only certain neighbors.

Advertisement

Woods has disputed in the past, the group’s ability to claim it had done anything for 20 years or more, because the assocation’s membership lapsed with the state after failing to file annual reports in 1981 and 1994. Broad Cove Association first filed with the state in 1962. The neighborhood group asserts that whether recognized by the state or not, they’ve always maintained the easement and used the beach.

In July, a new organization with the same name filed its charter with the Secretary of State’s Office, and is listed as an active non-profit corporation in state records.

“It remains to be seen whether the formation of the Broad Cove Shore Association in July, 2005, is consistent with asserting a 20-year prescriptive easement,” Woods said in November.

Even if the Broad Cove neighborhood is allowed to cross Woods’s land, the activities allowed there could be limited. Things like sunbathing might not be allowed, according to “Public Shoreline Access in Maine,” a guide published by the University of Maine, which cites a Maine Supreme Court decision regarding Moody Beach in Wells, which ruled that public access to the area between the high and low tide marks is only allowed for “fishing, fowling and navigation.”

Paul Woods, of 20 Running Tide Road, Cape Elizabeth claims only residents in the J lots shown on this land deed, from the Registry of Deeds at the Cumberland County Courthouse, have legal access to the a parcel of beach known as Secret Beach.

Comments are no longer available on this story