Some Scarborough residents were not happy with proposed changes to the town’s comprehensive plan after hearing the Comprehensive Plan Update Committee’s recommendations at a meeting Tuesday night.
The meeting centered on the town’s future land use plan, a portion of the comprehensive plan that designates where future growth should occur in town.
The committee is recommending the town continue its policy of not extending water and sewer across the turnpike, except in limited instances for commercial purposes, in order to control residential development.
This upset Dave Green, a landowner on Beech Ridge Road, who felt the town was treating the residents of West Scarborough like second-class citizens. While he was not advocating large-scale development in the area, he felt the lack of water and sewer was a major issue.
“Why won’t you cross with city water up Beech Ridge Road and Broad Turn Road to give us some public safety,” Green said.
Green also disliked the proposed building permit cap for West Scarborough, which specifies that no more than 25 percent of the units authorized for construction may occur in the region. He felt existing homeowners should be able to bypass this proposal.
Another West Scarborough resident felt the plan should contain an opportunity to allow for some small store in West Scarborough. The plan is proposing to only include commercial zoned areas on the portion of County Road to Gorham Road.
Another issue that was raised was a proposal to create Oak Hill into a more pedestrian friendly area. However there were some at the meeting that felt the chance of people walking from the dry cleaners to the hardware store was unlikely.
But Steve Berg, who manages the Oak Hill property, said there are many pedestrians walking around the plaza and the concept was not to necessarily connect the Oak Hill plaza outside of the area, but to provide people with more safety as they walk in the plaza.
Scarborough resident Matt Ward felt the plan should better address the Eastern Trail area from Pine Point Road to Saco and said there is a chance for an excellent recreation trail, he said.
“I would like to see the town make a commitment to preserve that old railroad bed as a permanent recreation, wildlife area,” Ward said.
Town Councilor Patrick O’Reilly did not like the fact that the committee is recommending that a half-mile area of Dunstan be zoned into six different categories, which he said creates a confusing situation. In addition, he noted that the three motels now in the area were proposed to be in zoning districts that did not allow motels.
Sylvia Most, co-chairman of the update committee, said the reason for such zoning diversity in the area is because the committee tried to accommodate current uses as best it could.
Overall, the committee is recommending increasing the density in some areas in town while decreasing density correspondingly in other areas to help control growth. The plan provides developers with more opportunity to build a wider array of housing to include apartments, condominiums and smaller house. It also allows multi-use residential/business buildings.
The committee’s recommendations also include a provision to increase the number of industrial areas in town to compensate for areas that have already been developed. It also allows for commercial development in new areas. The plan recommended by the committee also suggests that most commercial areas in town allow for small businesses such as restaurants, offices, small-scale retail and financial services and institutions.
The comprehensive plan is only a recommendation and the Town Council must make any zoning changes. If the council chooses not to make changes, the plan must be altered accordingly.
“The plan is a draft, there is a long process for rezoning at a later date,” said Most.
The plan and its accompanying maps are available at Town Hall and also on the town’s Web site at www.scarborough.me.us.
Comments are no longer available on this story