The code enforcement office for the town of Scarborough hired an engineering firm from Boston to assist in the evaluation of the high school construction project. This was considered business as usual as the town doesn’t have the expertise on staff to monitor a project of this size and magnitude.
Common sense would dictate that having another layer of quality assurance would be prudent, especially considering the many questionable construction-related issues that were detailed in a series of photographs and emails that I presented last March to the school board.
It’s disappointing that a school administration official was quoted in the Current last week as stating “To spend another $25,000 to second guess the top architectural firm in the state always seemed a little ludicrous to me.”
Dismissing this report with this type of commentary does not serve the public interest well. I would submit that it would have been ludicrous not to spend additional funds to protect the $27 million investment made by the taxpayers of Scarborough, the largest locally funded project in the history of the state of Maine.
The major structural components of this building are designed for a life span of 100 years. The engineering report identifies seven areas of concern that may impact the long-term structural integrity of the building and recommended the town obtain a long-term insurance policy that will cover any repairs required in the future relating to these issues.
There are numerous references in the report about certain aspects of this project not being consistent with BOCA code, not meeting ASTM standards or AWS specifications, or not following the designer’s specifications. The citizens of this community have an inherent right to expect that this building will be constructed up to all building standards and bid specifications. That is what the construction management team agreed to do in the contract and that is what the citizens that wrote the check expect.
To quote from the report concerning 27 full length cracks in 117 feet of foundation wall: “If the cracks are larger than the ACI allowable, moisture from the surrounding earth could infiltrate the concrete wall. During the natural freeze thaw cycles this could cause the concrete cracks to increase in size until eventually the reinforcement is exposed to corrosive elements. If the reinforcement begins to corrode, the lifespan of the foundation wall could be reduced.”
Concerning anchor bolts that were bent into position: “”If there is a reduction in performance due to the multiple bending of the ASTM F 1554 bolts or the single bending of the epoxy grouted B7 bolts, there may be concerns about the performance of the anchor bolts over the lifetime of the structure.”
Concerning the use of plug welds in column base plates: “We believe that the AWS specification prohibits using plug welds to secure column base plates to broken anchor bolts in columns that resist lateral loading,” and “It is prudent to anticipate some unexpected column uplift from wind or seismic events in gravity columns. Geometric imperfections of structural members may also cause unforeseen stresses in the frame leading to uplift. Such examples of uplift, which may be small, will place tension on the plug weld anchor bolt connections. A seismic event could potentially damage many of the plug weld to anchor bolt connections, which could reduce the life expectancy of the structure.”
There is a common theme in the aforementioned references to the engineering report concerning long-term structural integrity, which was the primary focus of my presentation to the Town Council and school board many months ago. The engineering report validates these concerns as legitimate with a recommendation to secure a long-term insurance policy to protect the taxpayers of Scarborough from future costs related to this work.
It would a sound idea for the school district to obtain this policy and do so at the expense of those that didn’t do the work right in the first place. The public needs to have the full faith and confidence that the building they paid for with their hard-earned tax dollars will not be a financial albatross in the future. With another significant school infrastructure question looming on the horizon it would be better for school officials to proactively deal with this report rather than dismissing it out of hand.
Jeffrey Messer
Chairman, Scarborough Town Council
Comments are no longer available on this story