Being NaA? ?ve Will Not Stop The Madness in Iraq
Once upon a time, I was a dyed-in-the-wool conservative. How conservative, you ask? Consider my early history, if you will. I am an Army veteran of the Vietnam War, discharged honorably in late 1968. When South Vietnam was overrun seven years later, I was so irate at my fellow Americans for allowing this to happen that I left a secure and well paying job and went back into the military (U. S. Coast Guard).
Instead of blaming my government for a failed policy, I laid it squarely on the cowardly and reprehensible actions of anti-war protestors who forced our politicians to turn their backs on 58,000 dead American soldiers – and thereby thrusting hundreds of thousands of other Vietnam veterans to suffer not only combat post-traumatic stress disorder but a lifetime of shame and guilt believing that we had failed in Vietnam. I was an embittered man who struggled with his feelings for a very long time. But, in retrospect, I was also a very naA? ?ve young man.
In 1964 I was naA? ?ve enough to believe my government when it said our navy was attacked by North Vietnamese patrol boats in the Gulf of Tonkin, which led to a massive escalation of our involvement in South Vietnam. It was only many years later, when the Tonkin Gulf incident was considered to be dubious at best, that the lights in my brain flickered on and I began to realize that the government had misled us. I vowed to never be that naA? ?ve again.
And I’ve kept that promise. I was not naA? ?ve in 2001 to believe that Iraq attacked us on 9/11. We were attacked by Islamic fundamentalist terrorists led by Osama Bin Laden, a Saudi. Fifteen of the 19 hijackers that day were Saudis, and they were all funded by Bin Laden. Iraq’s Saddam Hussein was the dictator of a secular Arab country who, White House intelligence czar Richard Clarke asserted, had nothing to do with 9/11. This assertion was later corroborated (after the invasion of Iraq started) by President Bush himself, when in an interview he stated “that they had no evidence that Saddam Hussein was involved in the attacks of 9/11.” Therefore, why are we in Iraq?
The answer is simple. The naivety of the American People who wanted to strike back at anything Arab. The Bush Administration initially got it right. They attacked fundamentalist Islamic terrorists in Afghanistan, where they were trained and headquartered. The early successes emboldened the administration Neo-Conservatives to employ the war on terror to confuse us into believing that Iraq was the real threat.
All the weapons-of-mass-destruction, nuclear-threats and connection-to-9/11 rhetoric was just a springboard to do what they had wanted to do all along – to establish a U.S.-friendly, oil-rich Arab state that advances the Neo-Conservative dream of world economic dominance. Much like the spread of communism was the catalyst for our need to prop-up a puppet government in South Vietnam then, the war on terror was the catalyst for regime change today.
Our present day situation parallels the U. S. experience in Vietnam so strikingly it is eerie. The questions to be answered are many. Should we get out? How do we get out? What about the brave men and women of our armed forces who have, along with their families, sacrificed so much? What can we do? More importantly, what are the consequences of staying or leaving?
Not being so naA? ?ve at this stage of my life allowed me to weigh the questions and consequences in my mind, and I came to the conclusion that withdrawal from Iraq is the only sane avenue left to us for several reasons.
During the Vietnam War, we were not a debtor nation. Today we are. Countries such as China and Japan own over a trillion dollars and counting of our debt. Staying the course in Iraq, while at the same time handing out huge tax cuts to our wealthiest is an insane policy. Not only will it erode our economic future but most importantly greatly weaken our ability to fight terrorism anywhere.
The military’s ability to maintain its functionality in Vietnam was fueled by the draft. The draft gave our military then the luxury of guaranteeing one-year tours of duty in the combat zone. We knew there was a light at the end of the tunnel. Our all-volunteer forces are in large numbers, on their second and third tours of duty in combat areas. How much more can they mentally withstand? To continue this insanity will be disastrous to the readiness and stability of our military. One of Mr. Bush’s 2000 campaign promises was to strengthen and maintain a powerful defense. The administration has actually weakened our forces (especially the reserve components) so badly it had difficulty in properly responding during the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. The policy of staying in Iraq for several more years is unsustainable and dangerous to our national security.
The toughest question of all, however, is how do we tell the families of those killed in the Iraq War and the soldiers wounded that their sacrifices were not in vain? But do we want to see the casualties climb to 60,000 dead and 500,000 wounded – especially for an administration that misled and lied us into this war of choice? An administration run by a couple of chicken hawks who between them, have a clouded Air National Guard record and five deferments during the Vietnam War. Just think of the five deferments for a second. The “man” who now spews diatribes at those in our government who want to get out of Iraq, had to thoughtfully apply for every one of those deferments. How unpatriotic and spineless was that?
Our brave men and women did not sacrifice in vain. Years ago, I found a quote by the philosopher Seneca that helped me come to grips with the experience of Vietnam. In 85 B.C. he wrote the following:
“Men do not care how nobly they live, only how long. Although it is within the power of all men to live nobly, but no man’s power to live long.”
The men and women of our armed forces who have paid with their lives, limbs and minds chose the noble path. They served their country and served it well. They accomplished the mission of bringing down the regime of Saddam Hussein, and we as a people and a government must bring them home now. We owe it to them and our future heroes to be able to fight the real war on terror. We also owe them a vow to never let leaders cloaked in secrecy and the complete antithesis of the above quote come to power again. Stopping the madness in Iraq is step one to accomplishing that goal.
David Lindholm
Scarborough
Comments are no longer available on this story