5 min read

Members of the South Portland Historical Society have worried for months about whether they can raise the $400,000 needed to buy the historic Cushing Point’s house and make it a permanent home for the nonprofit.

Now the early 20th-century captain’s home may be theirs free of charge.

In an unexpected turn of events, the Portland Pipeline Corp. – which owns the property – is exploring whether to donate the old brick building to the historical society, as long as the group moves it to a new site. The Portland Pipeline board is expected to vote on the donation when it meets Sept. 16.

The news was welcomed by members of the South Portland City Council Monday night, which heard a request by City Manager Jim Gailey to provide city land at the entrance of Bug Light Park as the new building site.

The house now occupies land at the end of Madison Street, which leads to Bug Light Park. The vacant city land is across Madison Street, not far from the public boat ramp.

“I can’t imagine anyone being against this idea,” said Councilor Linda Boudreau, who disclosed that she is a proud, dues-paying member of the historical society. “I am not without bias.”

Advertisement

Several other councilors raised their hands to acknowledge that they are donors to the society’s building campaign, are society members – or both.

“I compliment the society for taking this idea and running with it,” said Councilor Tom Blake.

Pipeline officials are in discussions with the society to move the house, because it would allow the company to clear the land and expand a petroleum handling facility at a pier near the site.

Portland Pipeline bought the property in 2000, when it purchased several acres extending down to the water. Several private investors have sought to buy the old home. But Portland Pipeline agreed to sell the house and some land around it to the historical society.

“They feel strongly we should have the house and it is ideal for a museum,” society director Kathy DiPhilippo said, when the group launched a fundraiser in 2007 to buy the property. “This building is historic for the story that is behind it. It has been witness to a lot of history.”

But the historical society has raised only $180,000 toward the purchase, and members have been concerned that the tough economy will continue to make fundraising a challenge.

Advertisement

At Monday night’s workshop, all seven councilors expressed enthusiasm and support for providing city-owned land to allow for the donation of the house to the historical society. Councilors agreed that it would send a positive message to the pipeline company that the city stands behind the proposal.

But DiPhilippo emphasized that a final decision has not been reached by the pipeline company. Local pipeline officials like the plan, but it needs the endorsement of the international board, she said. “We are moving forward… but don’t know what will happen.”

The company also has offered to subdivide the property to keep the vacant land it needs for the development, while allowing the house to stay where it is now. Under that plan, the pipeline company would be willing to sell the house and land for $300,000 – or $100,000 less than its original asking price.

But the society would need a variance from the city’s zoning board to operate the house as a museum, because it would no longer meet standards for building lot sizes.

Councilor Claude Morgan said moving the two-story brick home likely would benefit both the pipeline company and the historical society. He said it sounds as though the company might have to raze the building, if the society did not try to claim ownership.

Moving the home to nearby city land “keeps it in the area where it originated,” Gailey added. “That area now is scrub brush and broken pavement left over from the shipyard activities.”

Advertisement

The society and city leaders have a deep interest in preserving the building. Cushing’s Point House has come to represent important chapters in South Portland history. It is the only home from the early 1900s that remains on Madison Street in the Cushing’s Point neighborhood.

The U.S. Maritime Commission took most of the homes by eminent domain during World War II. They were either moved or demolished to expand shipbuilding for the war effort. During World War II, the large home was used as administrative offices for Liberty shipbuilding.

The acquisition by the historical society also would provide the group with a permanent home for its staff, files and artifacts. The group occupies small quarters in the basement of City Hall.

Developing Cushing’s Point House would enable the group to “exhibit its collections and interpret that history for people of all ages,” states the group’s Web site.

The money raised so far would go toward moving the house, connecting to utilities and making renovations.

“Ultimately, the council will be preserving a piece of South Portland’s history, while giving the Society a new place to call home,” Gailey told councilors.

Advertisement

City officials agreed that staff can iron out technical details, such as whether to license the society to use the land or provide an easement with conditions. Gailey said those terms need to cover the society’s responsibilities for maintenance, utilities, insurance and general operations.

Gailey noted that there is electricity and water at the site but not an active sewage line. He said there is an abandoned pump station nearby. Councilors agreed that the society would have to bear the expense of sewage hookup.

Blake said this may be an opportune time for the city to address drainage problems at popular Bug Light Park and also consider adding bathrooms there. He said that the fire chief is unhappy with the water supply near Bug Light Park.

Mayor Jim Soule said he sees the effort to secure and move the house as a “win-win-win” situation for the city, the pipeline company and the historical society.

The house will be much more visible to visitors at the new location, he said. “If we do the right thing” by providing the land, “then (Portland Pipeline) can step forward and say that the city has shown its commitment.”

Unexpectedly, historical society may be given Cushing’s Point houseUnexpectedly, historical society may be given Cushing’s Point house

Comments are no longer available on this story